Showing posts with label genetic drift. Show all posts
Showing posts with label genetic drift. Show all posts

Sunday, July 4, 2021

Let's get Genetic Drift in K-12 evolution education standards

An undergraduate reflecting back on what they learned in introductory human origins and evolution. 

Perpetual chance change is the only way evolution makes sense to me. Without it, natural selection, none of it, makes sense to me. It seems to be true for my students as well. Check out these three examples. 

1. “When I learned about evolution in high school, I may have known the biological mechanism (mutations) and natural selection, but I did not know about genetic drift and gene flow. Out of those two, I thought genetic drift was more surprising to learn about. I always thought evolution was driven by natural selection, “survival of the fittest.” While that may produce the most rapid change in organisms, evolution is always happening through genetic drift. Mutations are always occurring and if a mutation is passed down parent to offspring that does not impede the offspring from reproducing then that mutation will appear in the subsequent generations. The mutation does not have to have any inherit benefits, the organism just has to survive until successful reproduction. I liked the catchphrase of genetic drift “survival of that which does not suck too badly.””

2. “One new thing I learned this week was genetic drift. I believe genetic drift was briefly mentioned in my biology class, but I was very confused on what it was and how it played a role in evolution. I was interested to learn about genetic drift, because it opened up my eyes to realize that evolution didn't just occur because of "survival of the fittest" and geographic isolation. Evolution also occurred in part because of random chance. This concept makes total sense, and yet before learning about it, it had never crossed my mind. While Darwin was correct in his principles on the theory of evolution, it is important to remember that there is more to evolution (and more people who contributed to our knowledge of evolution) than just Darwin. APG 201 and learning about genetic drift helped me to realize that this week.”

3. "I was also fascinated to learn about genetic drift because I have always wondered if there is any accidental evolution of traits.  It was really interesting to learn that traits can in fact disappear through evolution accidentally even if they weren't necessarily undesirable traits. Evolution is not always carrying forward only hand-picked traits. There are random, unintentional chances in alleles that still happen and contribute to evolution. This is pretty cool because I often find myself (when learning about evolution) wondering how the traits of a species were important to them and what role they had in the evolution of the species. For example, did an animal only evolve brown fur because they can hide better? According to genetic drift, the allele for white fur may have just been bred out unintentionally. I now know that sometimes a trait doesn't have an intentional role in helping the species at all, genetic drift may just have caused this trait randomly.”

**

In the USA, K-12 evolution education standards are missing GENETIC DRIFT as well as the word NEUTRAL.

(see here: https://www.nextgenscience.org/topic-arrangement/hsnatural-selection-and-evolution)

I don't know how to understand life's perpetual change without those fundamentals.

If students know about meiosis (which *is* in the standards), then they know about genetic drift. It's just a matter of linking meiosis to evolution. 

Genetic drift is a very simple concept and makes natural selection make a whole lot more sense!

I shout about this on Twitter and I get "just be happy anyone teaches evolution in K-12 at all" and "teachers don't know about drift" in response. But evolution without genetic drift is not evolution, and if teachers knew about drift, then they'd be more comfortable teaching evolution. I guarantee it! 

Without drift, it's too easy to just replace God with natural selection. And that habit of narrating evolution by giving agency to natural selection is super-duper weird for non-believers let alone for believers! (This a no hatred of religion, faith, or creationism zone.)

Genetic drift paves the way for thinking about and then narrating evolution as the constant change that life/nature/biology is. Everyone gets that time is just constant change and they will get that  nature/biology/life is too. They embody it themselves, being different from their parents. 

Plus, continuing to teach evolution as only being natural selection (which is what the standards are doing), is also dangerous. That selection-obsessed mindset is tied to racism, sexism, essentialism... all the stuff that we have to remove from our species' shared origin story. Darwin only had selection (not drift, etc) to work with and look what his imagination did with evolution: racism, sexism, essentialism

If we want to get the science right which will also improve its cultural consequences, then we have to teach genetic drift to our kids when they are learning evolution. 

Perpetual. Chance. Change. That's all it is. 

But it's a big part of how we're going to remove the racism, sexism, etc from our species' shared origin story and finally write one that is worthy of all humankind. A story that we all deserve. 

I do not know how to even begin to suggest, or lobby for, these changes to people with actual power over K-12 education standards. If you do, please consider pointing me in the right direction and I'd be so grateful: holly_dunsworth at uri.edu

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Darwin the Newtonian. Part V. A spectrum, not a dogma

Our previous installments on genetic drift (a form of chance) vs natural selection (a deterministic force-like phenomenon) and the degree to which evolution is due to each (part 1 here) lead to a few questions that we thought we'd address to end this series.

First, there is no sense in which we are suggesting that complex traits arise out of nowhere, by 'chance' alone.  There is no sense in which we are suggesting that screening for viability or utility does not occur as a regular part of evolution.  But we are asking what the nature of that screening is, and what a basically deterministic, Newtonian view of natural selection, that is we believe widely if often tacitly held, implies and how accurate it may be.

It's also important here to point out something that is obvious.  The dynamics of evolution from both trait and genome level comprise a spectrum of processes, not a single one that should be taken as dogma.  A spectrum means that there is a range of relative roles of what can be viewed as determinism and chance that the two are not as distinct as may seem, and that even identifying, much less proving what is going on in a given situation is often dicey.  Some instances of strong selection, like some of chance seem reasonably clear and those concepts are apt.  But much, perhaps most, of evolution is a more subtle mix of phenomena and that is what we are concerned with.

Secondly, we have discussed our view of natural selection before, in various ways.  In particular, we cite our series on what we called the 'mythology' of selection, a term we used to be provocative in the sense of hopefully stimulating readers to think about what many seem to take for granted.  Yes, we're repeating ourselves some, but think the issues are important and our ideas haven't been refuted in any serious way so we think they're worth repeating.

A friend and former collaborator took exception to our assumption that people still believe that what we see today is what was the case in the past.  He felt we were setting up a straw man. The answer is somewhat subjective, but we believe that if you read many, many descriptions of current function and their evolution, you'll see that they are often if not usually just equated de facto with being 'adaptations', and that means that doing what they do now came about because it was favored by the force of selection in the past.  We think it's not a straw man at all, but a description of what is being said by many people much of the time: very superficial, dogmatic assumptions both of determinative selection and that we can infer the functional reason.

Of course everyone acknowledges that earlier states had their own functions and today's came from earlier, and that functions change (bat wings used to be forelegs, e.g.), but the idea is that bat flight is here because the way bats fly was selected for.  One common metaphor going back to an article by Lewontin and Gould is that evolution works via 'spandrels', traits evolved for one purpose or incidentally part of some adaptation, that are then usable by evolution to serve some new function. Yes, evolution works through changing traits, but how often are they 'steps' in this sense or is the process more like a rather erratic escalator, if we need a metaphor?

There are ways for adaptive traits to arise that have nothing to do with Darwinian competition for limited resources, and are perfectly compatible with a materialist view.  Organismal selection occurs when organisms who 'like' a particular part of their environment, tend to hang out there.  They'll meet and mate with others who are there as well.  If the choice has to do with their traits--ability to function at high altitude, or whatever--then over time this trait will become more common in this niche compared to their peers elsewhere, and eventually mating barriers may arise, and a new species with what appears to be a selected adaptation. But no differential reproduction is required--no natural selection.  It's natural assortment instead.

All aspects of our structure and function depend on interaction among molecules.  If two molecules must interact for some function to occur, then mutant versions may not serve that purpose and the organism may perish. This would seem most important during embryonic development.  An individual with incompatible molecular interactions (due to genetic mutation) would simply not survive.  This leaves the population with those whose molecules do interact, but there is no competition involved--no natural selection.  It's natural screening instead.

Natural selection of the good ol' Darwinian kind can occur, leading to complex adaptations in just the way Darwin said 150+ years ago.  But if the trait is the result of very many genes, the individual variants that contribute may be invisible to selection, and hence come and go essentially by chance. This is what we have called phenogenetic drift.  Do you doubt that?  If so, then why is it that most complex traits that are mapped can take on similar values in individuals with very different genotypes?  This is, if anything, the main bottom line finding of countless very large and extensive mapping studies, in humans and even bacteria.  This is basically what Andreas Wagner's work, that we referred to earlier in the series, is about.   It rather obviously implies that which of equivalent variants proliferates is the result of chance.  There's nothing non-Darwinian about this.  It's just what you'd expect instead.

We'd expect this because the many factors with which any species must deal will challenge each of its biological systems. That means many screening factors (better we think than calling them selection 'pressures' as would usually be done).  Most of these are affected by multiple genes.  Genes vary within a population.  If any given factor's effects were too strong, it would threaten the species' existence.  At least, most must be relatively weak at any given time, even if persisting over very long time periods.  Multiple traits, multiple contributing genes in this situation means that relative to any one trait or gene, the screening must be rather weak.  That in turn means that chance affects which variant proliferates.  There's nothing non-Darwinian about this.  It's essentially why he stressed the glacial slowness of evolution.

There is, however, the obvious fact that known functional parts of DNA are far less variable than regions with no known function.  This can be, and usually is assumed to be, the expected evidence of Darwinian natural selection.  But factors like organismal dispersion or functional (embryonic) adequacy can account for at least some of this.  Longer-standing genes and genetic systems would be expected to be more entrenched because they can acquire fewer differences before they won't work with other elements in the organism.  This is at least compatible with the view we've expressed, and there could be some ways of testing the explanation.

This view means we need not worry about whether a variant is 'truly' neutral in the face of environmental screening.  We could even agree that there's no testable sense in which a variant evolves by 'pure' chance. Even very tiny differences in real function can evolve in a way that is statistically 'neutral'.  Again, this can be the case even if the trait to which such variants contribute is subject to clear natural or other forms of selection.

This view is also wholly compatible with the findings of GWAS, the evidence that every trait is affected by genetic variation to some extent, the fact that organisms are adapted to their environment in many ways and the fact that prediction based on genotyping is often a problematic false promise.  And because this is a spectrum, randomly generated by mutation, some variants and or traits they affect will be very harmful or helpful--and will look like strong, force-like natural selection.  These variants and traits led to Mendel, and led to the default if often tacit assumption that natural selection is the force that explains everything in life.

Further, it is important for all the same sorts of reasons that the shape of the spectrum--the relative amount of a given level of complexity--is not based on any distribution we know of and hence is not predictable, generally because it is the result of a long history of random and local context and contingencies, of various unknown strength and frequency (about the past, we can estimate a distribution but that doesn't mean we understand any real underlying probabilistic process that caused what we see).  This is interesting, because many aspects of genetic variation (and of the tree of life) can be fitted to a reasonable extent to various probability distributions (see Gene Koonin's paper or his book The Logic of Chance).  But these really aren't causal parametric 'laws' in the usual sense, but descriptions after the fact without rigorous causal characteristics.  Generally, prediction of the future will be weak and problematic.

In the view of life we've presented, evolution will have characteristics that are weak or unpredictable directional tendencies, and the same for genetic specificities (and hence predictive power). It is the trait that is in a sense predictable, not the effects of individual genes.

We think this view of evolution is compatible with the observed facts but not with many of the simplified ideas that are driving life sciences at present.

Our viewpoint is that the swarm of factors environmental and genomic means that chance is a major component even of functional adaptations, in the biodesic paths of life.

Tuesday, May 10, 2016

Darwin the Newtonian. Part IV. What is 'natural selection'?

If, as I suggested yesterday, genetic drift is a rather unprovable or even metaphysical notion, then what is the epistemological standing of its opposite: not-drift?  That concept implies that the reproductive success of the alternative genotypes under consideration is not equal. But since we saw yesterday that showing that two things are exactly equal is something of a non-starter, how different is its negation?  

Before considering this, we might note that to most biologists, those who think and those who just invoke explanations, non-drift means natural selection.  That is what textbooks teach, even in biology departments (and in schools 
of medicine and public health, where simple-Simon is alive and well). But natural selection implies systematic, consistent favoring of one variant over others, and for the same reason.  That is by far the main rationale for the routine if unstated assumption that today's functions or adaptations are due to past selection for those same functions: we observe today and retroactively extrapolate to the past.  It's understandable that we do that, and it was a major indirect way (along with artificial selection) in which Darwin was able to reconstruct an evolutionary theory that didn't require divine ad hoc creation events.   But there are problems with this sort of thinking--and some of them have long been known, even if essentially stifled by what amounts to a selectionist ideology, that is, a rather unquestioning belief in a kind of single-cause worldview.

What does exactly not-zero mean?
I suggested yesterday that drift, meaning exactly no systematic difference between states (like genotypes) was so illusive as to be essentially philosophical.  But zero-difference is a very specific value and may thus be especially hard to prove.  But non-zero is essentially an open-ended concept and might thus be trivially easy to show.  But it's not!

One alternative to two things being not zero is simply that they have some difference.  But need that difference be specifiable or of a fixed amount?  Need it be constant or similar over instances of time and place?  If not, we are again in rather spooky territory, because not being identical is not much if any help in understanding.  One wants to know by how much, and why--and if it's consistent or a fluke of sample or local circumstance.  But this is not a fixed set of things to check.

Instead of just 'they're different', what is usually implicitly implied is that the genotypes being compared have some particular, specific fitness difference amount, not just that they differ. That is what asserting different functional effects of the variants largely implies, because otherwise one is left asserting that they are different....sort of, sometimes, and this isn't very satisfying or useful.  It would be normal, and sensible, to argue that the difference need not be precisely, deterministically constant, because there's always a luck component, and ecological conditions change.  But if the difference varies widely among circumstances, it is far more difficult to make persuasive 'why' explanations. For example, small differences favoring variant A over variant B in one sample or setting might actually favor B over A in other times or places.  Then selection is a kind of willy-nilly affair--which probably is true!--but much more difficult to infer in a neat way, because it really is not different from being zero on average (though 'on average' is also easier to say than to account for causally).  If a difference is 'not zero', there are an infinity of ways that might be so, especially if it is acknowledged to be variable, as every sensible evolutionary biologist would probably agree is the case.

But then looking for causes becomes very difficult because among all the variants in a population, and all the variation in individual organisms' experience means that there may be an open-ended  number of explanations one would have to test to account for an observed small fitness difference between A and B.  And that leads to serious issues about statistical 'significance' and inference criteria.  That's because most alleged fitness differences are essentially local and comparative.  In turn that means the variant is not inherently selected but is context-dependent: fitness doesn't have a universal value, like, say, G, the universal Newtonian gravitational constant in physics, and to me that means that even an implicitly Newtonian view of natural selection is mistaken as a generality about life. 

If selection were really force-like in that sense, rather than an ephemeral, context-specific statistical estimate, its amount (favoring A over B) should approach the force's parameter, analogous to G, asymptotically: the bigger the sample and greater the number of samples analyzed the closer the estimated value would get to the true value.  Clearly that is not the way life is, even in most well-controlled experimental settings.  Indeed, even Darwin's idea of a constant struggle for existence is incompatible with that idea.

There are clearly many instances in which selective explanations of the classical sort seem specifically or even generally credible.  Infectious disease and the evolution of resistance is an obvious example.  Parallel evolution, such as independent evolution of, say, flight or similar dog-like animals in Australia and Africa, may be taken to prove the general theory of adaptation to environments.  But what about all the not dogs in these places?  We are largely in ad hoc explanatory territory, and the best of evolutionary theory clearly recognizes that.

So, in what sense does natural selection actually exist?  Or neutrality?  If they are purely comparative, local, ad hoc phenomena largely demonstrable only by subjective statistical criteria, we have trouble asserting causation beyond constructing Just-So stories.  Even with a plausible mechanism, this will often be the case, because plausibility is not the same as necessity.  Just-So stories can, of course, be true....but usually hard to prove in any serious sense.

Additionally, in regard to adaptive traits within or between populations or species, if genetic causation is due to contributions of many genes, as typically seems to be the case, there is phenogenetic drift, so that even with natural selection working force-like on a trait, there may be little if any selection on specific variants in that mix: even if the trait is under selection, a given allelic variant may not be.

Some other slippery issues
Natural selection is somewhat strange.  It is conceptually a passive screen of variation, but often treated as if an inherent property of a genotype (or an allele), whose value is determined on what else is in the same locus in the population.  Yet it's also treated as if this is inherent and unchanging property of the genotype...until any competing genotypes disappear.  As the favored allele becomes more common, its amount of advantage will increasingly vary because, due to recombination and mutation, the many individuals carrying the variant will also vary in the rest of their genomes, which will introduce differences in fitness among them (likewise, early on most carriers of the favored 'A' variant will be heterozygotes, but later on more and more will be homozygotes).  When the A variant becomes very common in the population, its advantage will hardly be detectable since almost all its peers fellws will have the same genotype at that site.  Continued adaptation will have to shift to other genes, where there still is a difference.  Some AA carriers will have detrimental variants at another gene, say B, and hence reduced fitness. Relatively speaking, some A's, or eventually maybe all A's, will have become harmful, because even in classical Darwinian terms selection is only relative and local.  So, selection even in the force-like sense, is very non-Newtonian, because it is so thoroughly context-dependent.  

Another issue is somatic mutation.  The genotypes that survive to be transmitted to the next generation are in the germ line.  But every cell division induces some mutations, and depending on when and where during development or later life a mutation occurs, it could affect the traits of the individual.  Even if selection were a deterministic force, it screens on individuals and hence that includes any effects of somatic mutation in those individuals.  But somatic mutations aren't inherited, so even if the mechanism is genetic their effects will appear as drift in evolutionary terms.  

Most models of adaptive selection are trait-specific.  But species do not evolve one trait at a time, except perhaps occasionally when a really major stressor sweeps through (like an epidemic).  Generally, a population is always subject to a huge diversity of threats and opportunities, contexts and changes.  Every one of our biological systems is always being tested, of in many ways at once. Traits are also often correlated with one another, so pushing on one may be pulling on another.  That means that even if each trait were being screened for separate reasons, the net effect on any one of the must typically be very very small, even if it is Newtonian in its force-like nature.  

The result is something like a Japanese pachinko machine.  Pachinko is popular type of gambling in Japan. A flurry of small metal balls bounces down from the top more or less randomly through a jungle of pins and little wheels, before finally arriving at the bottom.  The balls bounce off each other on the way in basically random collisions. The payoff (we could say it's analogous to fitness) is based on the balls that, after all this apparent chaos, end up in a particular pocket at the bottom.  In biological analogy, each ball can represent a different trait or perhaps individuals in a population. They bounce around rather randomly, constrained only by the walls and objects there--nothing steers them specifically. What's in the pocket is the evolutionary result. 

Pachinko machine (from Google images)
 (you can easily find YouTube videos showing pachinkos in action)

All similes limp, and these collisions are probably in truth deterministic, even if far too too complex to predict the outcome.  Nonetheless, this sort of dynamics among individuals with their differing genes of varying and context-specific effects, in diverse and complex environments, suggests why in this dynamic complex, change related to a given trait will be a lot like drift; there are so many that if each were too strongly force-like extinction would be more likely the result.  Further, since most traits are affected by many parts of the genome, the intensity of selection on any one of them must be reduced to be close to the expectations of drift. Adaptive complexity is another reason to think that adaptive change must be glacially slow, as Darwin stressed many times, but also that selection is much less force-like, as a rule.  After the fact, seeing what managed to survive, it looks compatible with force-like, straight-line selection.

Here, the process seems to rest heavily on chance.  But as we discussed in a post in 2014 in a series on the modes and nature of natural selection, we likened the course that species take through time to the geodesic paths that objects take through spacetime, that is determined (and there it really does seem to be 'determined') by the splattered matter and energy in any point it passes through.

An overall view
This leaves us in something of a quandary.  We can easily construct criteria for making some inferences, in the stronger cases, and testing them in some experimental settings.  We can proffer imaginative scenarios to account for the presence of organized traits and adaptations.  But evolutionary explanations are often largely or wholly speculative.  This applies comparably to natural selection and to genetic drift as well, and these are not new discoveries although they seem to be in few peoples' interest to acknowledge them fully.

Darwin wanted to show by plausibility argument that life on earth was the result of natural processes, not ad hoc divine creation events.  He had scant concepts of chance or genetic drift, because his ideas of the mechanism of inheritance were totally wrong.  Concepts of probabilism and statistical testing and the like were still rather new and only in restricted use.  Darwin would have no trouble acknowledging a role for drift.  How he would respond to the elusiveness of these factors, and that they really are not 'forces', is hard to say--but he probably would vigorously try to defend systematic selection by arguing that what is must have gotten here by selection as a force. 

The causal explanation of life's diversity still falls far short of the kind of mathematical or deterministic rigor of the core physical sciences, and even of more historical physical sciences like geology, oceanography, and meteorology.  Until someone finds better ways (if they indeed are there to be found), much of evolutionary biology verges on metaphysical philosophy for reasons we've tried to argue in this series.  We should be honest about that fact, and clearly acknowledge it.

One can say that small values are at least real values, or that you can ignore small values, as in genetic drift.  Likewise one can say that small selective effects will vary from sample to sample because of chance and so on.  But such acknowledgments undermine the kinds of smooth inferences we naturally hunger for.  The assumption that what we see today is what was the case in the past is usually little more than an assumption. This is a main issue we should confront in trying to understand evolution--and it applies as well to the promises being made of 'precision' prediction of genomic causation in health and medicine.  The moving tide of innumerable genotypic ways to get similar traits, at any time, within or between populations, and over evolutionary time, needs to be taken seriously. 

It may be sufficient and correct to say, almost tautologically, that today's function evolved somehow, and we can certainly infer that it got here by some mix of evolutionary factors.  Our ancestors and their traits clearly were evolutionarily viable or we wouldn't be here.  So even if we can't really trace the history in specifics, we can usually be happy to say that, clearly, whales evolved to be able to live in the ocean.  Nobody can question that.  But the points I've tried to make in this series are serious ones worth thinking seriously about, if we really want to understand evolution, and the genetic causal mechanisms that it has produced.

Monday, May 9, 2016

Darwin the Newtonian. Part III. In what sense does genetic drift 'exist'?

It has been about 50 years since Motoo Kimora and King and Jukes proposed that a substantial fraction of genetic variation can be selectively neutral, meaning that the frequency of such an allele (sequence variant) in a population or among species changes by chance--genetic drift--and, furthermore, that selectively 'neutral' variation and its dynamics are a widespread characteristic of evolution (see Wikipedia: Neutral theory of molecular evolution). Because Darwin had been so influential with his Newtonian-like deterministic theory of natural selection, natural evolution was and still is referred to as 'non-Darwinian' evolution. That's somewhat misleading, if convenient as a catch-phrase, and often used to denigrate the idea of neutral evolution, because even Darwin knew there were changes in life that were not due to selection (e.g., gradual loss of traits no longer useful, chance events affecting fitness).

First, of course, is the 'blind watchmaker' argument.  How else can one explain the highly organized functionally intricate traits of organisms, from the smallest microbe to the largest animals and plants?  No one can argue that such traits could plausibly just arise 'by chance'!

But beyond that, the reasoning basically coincides with what Darwin asserted.  It takes a basically thermodynamic belief and applies it to life.  Mother Nature can detect even the smallest difference between bearers of alternative genotypes, and in her Newtonian force-like way, will proffer better success on the better genotype.  If we're material scientists, not religious or other mystics, then it is almost axiomatic that since a mutation changes the nature of the molecule, if for no other reason that it requires the use of a different nucleotide and hence the use and or production of at least slightly different molecules and at least slightly different amounts of energy.

The difference might be very tiny in a given cell, but an organism has countless cells--many many billions in a human, and what about a whale or tree! Every nonessential nucleotide has to be provided for each of the billions of cells, renewed each time any cell divides.  A mutation that deleted something with no important function would make the bearer more economical in terms of its need for food and energy. The difference might be small, but those who then don't waste energy on something nonessential must on average do better: they'll have to find less food, for example, meaning spend less time out scouting and hence exposed to predators, etc.  In short, even such a trivial change will confer at least a tiny advantage, and as Darwin said many times to describe natural selection, nature detects the smallest grain in the balance (scale) of the struggle for life.  So even if there is no direct 'function,' every nucleotide functions in the sense of needing to be maintained in every cell, creating a thermodynamic or energy demand.  In this Newtonian view, which some evolutionary biologists hold or invoke quite strongly, there simply cannot be true selective neutrality--no genetic drift!


The relative success of any two genotypes in a population sample will almost never be exactly the same, and how could one ever claim that there is no functional reason for this difference?  Just because a statistical test doesn't find 'significant' differences in the probabilistic sense that it's not particularly unusual if nothing is going on, tiny differences nonetheless obviously can be real.  For example, a die that's biased in favor of 6 can, by chance, come up 3 or some other number more often in an experiment of just a few rolls. Significance cutoff values are, after all, nothing more than subjective criteria that we have chosen as conventions for making pragmatic decisions (the reason for dice being this way is interesting, but beyond our point here).

But what about the lightning strikes?  They are fortuitous events that, obviously, work randomly against individuals in a population in a way unrelated to their genotypes, thus adding some 'noise' to their relative reproductive success and hence of allele (genetic variant) frequencies in the population over time.  That noise would also be a form of true genetic drift, because it would be due to a cause unrelated to any function of the affected variants, whose frequencies would change, at least to some extent, by chance alone. A common, and not unreasonable selectionist response to that is to acknowledge that, OK! there's a minor role for chance, but nonetheless, on average, over time, the more efficient version must still win out in the end: 'must', for purely physical/chemical energetics if no other reasons.  That is, there can be no such thing as genetic drift on average, over the long haul.  Of course, 'overall' and 'in the end' have many unstated assumptions.  Among the most problematic is that sample sizes will eventually be sufficiently great for the underlying physical, deterministic truth to win out over the functionally unrelated lightning-strike types of factors.

On the other hand, the neutralists argue in essence that such minuscule energetic and many other differences are simply too weak to be detected by natural selection--that is, to affect the fitness of their bearers.  Our survival and reproduction are so heavily affected by those genotypes that really do affect them, that the remaining variants simply are not detectable by selection in life's real, finite daily hurly-burly competition. Their frequencies will evolve just by chance, even if the physical and energetic facts are real in molecular terms.

But to say that variants that are chemically or physically different do not affect fitness is actually a rather strong assertion! It is at best a very vague 'theory', and a very strong assumption of Newtonian (classical physics) deterministic principles. It is by no means obvious how one could ever prove that two variants have no effect.


So we have two contending viewpoints.  Everyone accepts that there is a chance component in survival and reproduction, but the selectionist view sees that component as trivial in the face of basic physical facts that two things that are different really are different and hence must be detectable by selection, and the other view that true equivalence is not only possible but widespread in life.

When you think about it, both views are so vague and dogmatic that they become largely philosophical rather than actual scientific views.  That's not good, if we fancy that we are actually trying to understand the real world.  What is the problem with these assertions?

Can drift be proved?
Maybe the simplest thing in an empirical setting would just be to rule out genetic drift, and show that even if the differences between two genotypes are small in terms of fitness there is always at least some difference.  But it might be easier to take the opposite approach, and prove that genetic drift exists.  To that, one must compare carriers of the different genotypes and show that in a real population context (because that's where evolution occurs) there is no, that is zero difference in their fitness. But to prove that something has a value of exactly zero is essentially impossible!


Is each outcome equally likely?  How to tell?


Again to a dice-rolling analogy, a truly unbiased die can still come up 6 a different number of times than 1/6th of the number of rolls: try any number of rolls not divisible by 6!  In the absence of any true theory of causation, or perhaps to contravene the pure thermodynamic consideration that different things really are different, we have to rely on statistical comparisons among samples of individuals with the different competing genotypes.  Since there is the lightning-strike source of at least some irrelevant chance effects and no way to know all the possible ways the genotypes' effects might differ truly but only slightly, we are stuck making comparisons of the realized fitness (e.g., number of surviving offspring) of the two groups.  That is what evolution does, after all.  But for us to make inferences we must apply some sort of statistical criteria, like a significance cut-off value ('p-value') to decide. We may judge the result to be 'not different from chance', but that is an arbitrary and subjective criterion.  Indeed, in the context of these contending views, it is also an emotional criterion.  Really proving that a fitness difference is exactly zero without any real external theory to guide us, is essentially impossible.

All we can really hope to do without better biological theory (if such were to exist) is to show that the fitness difference is very small.  But if there is even a small difference, if it is systematic it is the very definition of natural selection!  Showing that the difference is 'systematic' is easier to say than do, because there is no limit to the causal ideas we might hypothesize.  We cannot repeat the study exactly, and statistical tests relate to repeatable events.

There's another element making a test of real neutrality almost impossible.  We cannot sample groups of individuals who have this or that variant and who do not differ in anything else.  Every organism is different, and so are the details of their environment and lifestyle experiences.  So we really cannot ever prove that specific variants have no selective effect, except by this sort of weak statistical test averaging over non-replicable other effects that we assume are randomly distributed in our sample.  There are so many ways that selection might operate, that one cannot itemize them in a study and rule out all such things.  Again, selectionists can simply smile and be happy that their view is in a sense irrefutable.

A neutralist riposte to this smugness would be to say that, while it's literally true that we can't prove a variant to confer exactly zero effect, we can say that it has a trivially small effect--that it is effectively neutral.  But there is trouble with that argument, besides its subjectivity, which is the idea that the variant in question may in other times and genomic or environmental contexts have some stronger effect, and not be effectively neutral.


A related problem comes from the neutralists' own idea that by far most sequence variants seem to have no statistically discernible function or effect.  That is not the same as no effect.  Genomes are loaded with nearly or essentially neutral variants by the usual sampling strategies used in bioinformatic computing, such as that neutral sites have greater variation in populations or between species than is found in clearly functional elements.  But this in no way rules out the possibility that combinations of these do-almost-nothings might together have a substantial or even predominant effect on a trait and the carriers' fitness.


After all, is not that just what have countless very large-scale GWAS studies shown? Such studies repeatedly, and with great fanfare, report that there are tens, hundreds, or even thousands of genome sites that have very small but statistically identifiable individual effects but that even these together still account for only a minority of the heritability, the estimate of the overall amount of contribution that genetic variation makes to the trait's variation.  That is, it is likely that many variants that individually are not detectably different from being neutral may contribute to the trait, and thus potentially to its fitness value, in a functional sense.


This is one of the serious and I think deeply misperceived implications of the very high levels of complexity that are clearly and consistently observed, which raises questions about whether the concept of neutrality makes any empirical sense, and remains rather a metaphysical or philosophical idea.  This is related to the concepts of phenogenetic drift that we discussed in Part II of this series, in which the same phenotype with its particular fitness can be produced by a multitude of different genotypes--the underlying alleles being exchangeable.  So are they neutral or not?

In the end, we must acknowledge that selective neutrality cannot be proved, and that there can always be some, even if slight, selective difference at work.  Drift is apparently a mythical or even mystical, or at least metaphoric concept.  We live in a selection-driven world, just as Darwin said more than a century ago.  Or do we?  Tune in tomorrow.

Monday, February 8, 2016

If mutations can go viral, adaptationism is less annoying.

Feb. 9, 2016: I have edited the paragraph beginning with "Exciting..." to remove details of mutation rates because my initial posting was probably wrong about coding vs. non-coding mutation rates. To fix that requires much more nuance than is relevant for the point I'm making in that paragraph, not to mention much more nuance than I'm capable of grasping immediately! Cheers and thanks to Daniel and Ken in comments below and to everyone who chimed in on Twitter. 
***
I always account for virally-induced mutation when I imagine the evolution of our genome. That's because I'll never forget this quote. Who could?
“Our genome is littered with the rotting carcasses of these little viruses that have made their home in our genome for millions of years.” - David Haussler in 2008 
Or this...
"Retroviruses are the only group of viruses known to have left a fossil record, in the form of endogenous proviruses, and approximately 8% of the human genome is made up of these elements." (source and see this)
Exciting virus discoveries aside, we're constantly mutating with each new addition to the human lineage. Thanks to whole genome sequencing, the rate of new mutation between human parent and offspring is becoming better known than ever before. We each have new single nucleotide mutations in the stretches of our DNA that are known to be functional (very little of the entire genome) and that are not (the majority of the genome). These are variants not present in our parents’ codes (for example, we might have a ‘T’ where there is a ‘A’ in our mother’s code). And there are also deletions and duplications of strings of letters in the code, sometimes very long ones. Estimates vary on parent-offspring mutation rate and that's because there are different sorts of mutations and individuals vary, even as they age, as to how many mutations they pass along, for example. Still, without any hard numbers (which I've left out purposefully to avoid the mutation rate debate), knowing that there is constant mutation is helpful for imagining how evolution works. And it also helps us understand how mutations even in coding regions aren't necessarily good nor bad. Most mutations in our genome are just riding along in our mutation-tolerant codes—where they will begin and where they will go no one knows!

And it's with that appreciation for constant, unpredictable, but tolerated mutation—of evolution's momentum, of a lineage's perpetual change, selection or not—on top of a general understanding of population genetics that just makes adaptation seem astounding. It makes it difficult to believe that adaptation is as common as the myriad adaptive hypotheses for myriad traits suggest.

That's because this new raw material for adaptation, this perpetual mutation, really is only a tiny fragment of everything that can be passed on. But, what's more, each of those itty bitty changes could be stopped in its tracks before going anywhere.

The good, the bad, and the neutral, they all need luck to pass them onto the next generation. That's right. Even the good mutations have it rough. Even the winners can be losers! Here are the ways a mutation can live or die in you or me:

The Brief or Wondrous Life of Mutations, Wow.

This view of mutation fits into that slow and stately process that Darwin described, despite his imagination chugging away before he had much understanding of genetics.

Of course, bottlenecks or being part small populations would certainly help our rogue underdogs proliferate, and swiftlier so, in future generations.

Still, trying to imagine how any of my mutations, including any that might be adaptive, could become fixed in a population is enough to make me throw Origin of Species across the room.

By "adaptive," I'm talking about "better" or "advantageous" traits and their inherited basis ... that ever-popular take on the classic Darwinian idea of natural selection and competition.

For many with a view of mutation like I spelled out above, it's much easier to conceptualize adaptation as the result of negative selection, stabilizing selection, and tolerant or weak selection than it is to accept stories of full-blown positive selection, which is what "Darwinian" usually describes (whether or not that was Darwin's intention). One little error in one dude's DNA plus deep time goes all the way to fixed in the entire species because those who were lucky enough to inherit the error passed it on more frequently, because they had that error, than anyone passed on the old version of that code? I guess what I'm saying is, it's not entirely satisfying.

But what if a mutation could be less pitiful, less lonely, less vulnerable to immediate extinction? Instead, what if a mutation could arise in many people simultaneously? What if a mutation didn't have to start out as 1/10,000? What if it began as 1,000/10,000?

That would certainly up its chances of increasing in frequency over time, and quickly, relative to the rogue underdog way that I hashed out in the figure above. And that means that if there was a mutation that did increase survival and reproduction relative to the status quo, it would have a better chance to actually take over as an adaptation. This would be aided, especially, if there was non-random mating, like assortative mating, creating a population rife with this beneficial mutation in the geologic blink of an eye.

But how could such a widespread mutation arise? This sounds so heartless to put it like this, but thanks to the Zika virus, it seems to me that viruses could do the trick.

Electron micrograph of Zika virus. (wikipedia)
I'd been trapped in thinking that viruses cause unique mutations in our genomes the way that copy errors do. But why should they? If they infect me and you, they could leave the same signatures in our genomes. And the number of infected/mutated could increase if the virus is transmitted via multiple species (e.g. mosquito and human, like Zika). If scientists figure out that the rampant microcephaly associated with the Zika virus is congenital, wouldn't this be an example* of the kind of large-scale mutation that I'm talking about? 

*albeit a horrifying one, and unlikely to get passed on because of its effects, so it's not adaptive whatsoever.

If viral mutations get into our gametes or into the stem cells of our developing embryos, then we've got germ-line mutation and we could have the same germ-line mutation in the many many genomes of those infected with the virus. As long as we survive the virus, and we reproduce, then we'll have these mutant babies who don't just have their own unique mutations, but they also have these new but shared mutations and the shared new phenotypes associated with them, simultaneously.

Why not? Well, not if there are no viruses that ever work like this.

We need some examples. The mammalian placenta, and its subsequent diversity, is said to have begun virally, but I can't find any writing that assumes anything other than a little snowflake mutation-that-could.

Anything else? Any traits that "make us human"? Any traits that are pegged as convergences but could be due to the mutual hosting of the same virus exacting the same kind of mutation with the same phenotypic result in separate lineages?

I've always had a soft spot for underdogs. And I've always given the one-off mutation concept the benefit of the doubt because I know that my imagination struggles to appreciate deep time. What choice do you have when you think evolutionarily? However, just the possibility that viruses can mutate us at this larger scale, even though I know of no examples, is already bringing me a little bit of hope and peace, and also some much needed patience for adaptationism.

***
Update: I just saw this published today, asking whether microcephaly and other virus-induced birth defects are congenital. Answer = no one knows yet: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/09/science/zika-virus-microcephaly-birth-defects-rubella-cytomegalovirus.html?partner=IFTTT&_r=1

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

Imagine no mutation.

Imagine no mutation.
I wonder if you can.
No means for new variation.
A creationist's view of Man.
Imagine all the people
learning it this way.

Boo-hoo, ewww.

I found out this semester that although most of my students in "Human Origins" had learned about natural selection, that relatively few of them had learned about mutation. 

Huh? Are people still stuck on Darwin? Apparently. 

Mutation requires a little bit of genetics to understand, but c'mon! Natural selection makes no sense without it. None.

And what's more, natural selection cannot be the all-powerful force that popular culture might have us believe when mutation is accounted for. Evolution is so much more fascinating with even a basic understanding of mutation. In this molecular-clock, whole-genome-sequencing era, how can anyone teaching and learning evolution not have at least a basic understanding of chance, perpetual accumulation of mutations?

We've all, each and every one of us, got many de novo mutations. So our genomes are distinct from our parents' and siblings', not just because of genetic recombination of our grandparents' genomes when our parents' eggs and sperms were built, but because of unique mutations that occurred while making those germ cells or in the early stages after their union.

That this constant change in lineages is occurring with each reproductive event is proof that natural selection is a largely tolerant process, perpetually allowing perpetual evolution by mutation.

(And, maybe natural selection has much less, and mutation has much more, to do with speciation than many have assumed.)

What happens to each and every one of our unique mutations, whether or not they live on in our offspring, whether or not they play a role in adaptation, depends on quite a bit of luck, partly because of the "Law of Segregation":

A Mutation's Future
Click to enlarge. Email me for original file that you can modify: holly_dunsworth@uri.edu

For a description of evolution that incorporates perpetual mutation, check out "Evolution is the only natural explanation. And it's all we need."

Monday, March 24, 2014

Are we removing the wisdom along with the teeth?

When I was a kid, I learned that my uncle had a sweet tooth right about the time I discovered that he had a gold tooth. Therefore the gold tooth was the sweet tooth and, man-o-man, did I want a gold tooth... or a whole grill of gold teeth. The better to taste the sweets!

I've grown wiser with age, knowing, of course, that our teeth don't taste sweets (or at least that it's unconventional to think so). And knowing, of course, that "wisdom teeth" don't bestow wisdom, but are nicknamed so because they erupt last, coinciding with the stage in our lives when we're old enough to do adult things, both according to biology and culture.

Whether or not wisdom is actually present or actually required to vote, to smoke, or to make babies is not the point. The point is, like with whole sweet tooth thing, I understand that wisdom teeth don't come with wisdom, but sometimes I do wonder whether this massive, automatic third molar removal system that we've created for everyone in America who's got dental insurance is removing more than just enamel and dentine from our heads.

What if we're also removing a bit of our minds?

Okay. That's just me, losing a bit of my mind, thanks to an enormous pile of papers I've been grading.

But the metaphor's got teeth, given how the assignment I just graded was about... dun dun duuuuunnnn... the oft spun story of our species' future without third molars.

This assignment that I'm grading got me wondering about wisdom loss because the overwhelming majority of students could not do it.  Here it is:

The future of human wisdom teeth
Instructions
1. Read this blurb  about a very common perception of human evolution. (source)




About 25 to 35 per cent of people will never get their wisdom teeth (RAFFI ANDERIAN)
Wisdom teeth might be lost as people continue to evolve: Why the modern diet may make wisdom teeth unnecessary 
By: Astrid Lange Toronto Star Library, Published on Tue Jun 25 2013 
Wisdom teeth are the third and final set of molars that most people get in their late teens or early 20s. But not everyone does — the American Dental Association estimates that about 25 to 35 per cent of people will never get their wisdom teeth. Another 30 per cent will only get 1 to 3 of them. Anthropologists believe wisdom teeth evolved due to our ancestors’ diet of coarse, rough food — leaves, roots, nuts and meat — which required more chewing power and resulted in excessive wear of the teeth. Since people are no longer ripping apart meat with their teeth and the modern diet is made of softer foods, wisdom teeth have become less useful. In fact, some experts believe we are on an evolutionary track to losing them altogether.
2. On a separate piece of paper…(typed is preferred but not required)
a. Briefly explain the evolutionary mechanism(s) behind the evolutionary scenario for future wisdom tooth loss that the author of the blurb alludes to. In other words, think about what the writer is really hypothesizing for future human evolution and rephrase it, scientifically, in terms of the four main mechanisms of evolution that we discussed in class which are mutation, gene flow, genetic drift, and selection.
b. Write out an alternative scenario where natural selection is responsible for the loss of wisdom teeth in our future selves. If it’s not obvious, this will be an obviously and significantly different scenario from what the writer has imagined in the blurb. Important! Banned words for your scenario include: Need(s/ed/ing), want(s/ed/ing), try(s/ed/ing), best, most.

***

Only a handful of students performed this assignment correctly.

Despite my hints in 2b, most still wrote 2a using natural selection. Few spoke of mutation let alone drift in their answer to 2a. What's more, many used genetic drift scenarios (without using the term) for 2b!!! If they got anywhere close to the right answer in 2b then they stopped at something like "mutation arises and it proliferates in future generations"... no talk of a benefit to losing teeth or a cost to having them, no talk of adaptation. This is drift and they think it's natural selection. Or they're sloppy writers. Or both.

So what's going on here? Lots. Here's a little bit of my analysis:

First, it's true that I deliberately chose this example, the future wisdom tooth-less humankind, because it is a well-known scenario out there and I knew that unraveling it would be a challenge as a result of its fame. It's a great example of the kind entrenched in the popular zeitgeist about trait loss and future evolution. And so I wanted to take it head on, but I didn't expect such utter and nearly complete failure in this learning environment I tried to cultivate.

Yet again, I'm reminded that stories stick. Not just stories about our future without M3s, but just-so stories like adaptation by natural selection. Selection stories stick so well that students think any and every evolutionary scenario they come across or that they dream up is nothing other than natural selection!

I have to tell them, as I often do, how great they are at genetic drift and how great they already were at genetic drift before entering my classroom. Yet they continue to insist that genetic drift is natural selection.

The textbook certainly doesn't help. I hadn't looked at the definitions in the glossary until a student used one in his answer... Check this out:

"natural selection. Differential reproductive success over multiple generations."

That also defines genetic drift!

A few students admitted to not having any wisdom teeth at all growing in, or to knowing someone who never got theirs (not even crowns in the crypts). So they understand that there's already variation, or that there hypothetically very easily could be. They get the concept of variation because they're surrounded by human variation and they see themselves as unique. They know they're not clones of either of their parents too. 

So why is it so hard (and even "confusing" as I've been told by a student) for them to accept perpetual change via mutation, recombination, and probabilistic inheritance of one or the other allele from each parent. Mutation and drift... these are constantly occurring and have been for millions and billions of years. Natural selection allows this persistent, perpetual change in lineages and populations! What's more, if everything was under natural selection, if everything is evolving only due to natural selection, we'd be so screwed! From my perspective, it doesn't make any scientific sense to be a hyper-adaptationist. To me, it's a creationist's way of thinking.

But what would anyone expect from a student who's been bombarded with natural selection as "*the* mechanism of evolution" (quote from episode 2 of Cosmos with NdGT)? What would anyone expect from a student who's learning evolution at the college level from, either, folks who are suspicious of it for its social abuses (stemming from that very obsession with natural selection!) or from folks who study evolution itself (which means that, if they're successful, if they have papers published at all let alone in the top journals, then they default to natural selection as an explanation for the trait or the phenomenon they're studying, and usually don't ditch their adaptive explanation unless it's replaced by another adaptive one).

What else would I expect from my students? This is what I should have expected. So I can't believe I thought that they'd do better on this assignment after only one lecture on the mechanisms of evolution from me, after only one momentary exposure to genetic drift.

But since then, lucky for them, they've heard about these issues every single day. And maybe someday down the road "arrival of the frequent" will be better understood both within and beyond the classroom as well. Who knows.

Does it count as a good place to start when most fail? It certainly does since the only direction from here is up.

Except there's the fact that many if not most of my students have had their wisdom teeth removed already or have plans to this year or next. I too have had my wisdom teeth removed. So maybe we're a lost cause.

Or maybe not. It's possible that wisdom or at least experience can be an obstacle to learning. With age, we lose plasticity. That whole, you-can't-teach-an-old-dog-new-tricks sentiment is sort of kind of true for people, regardless of whether it's true for dogs. Very young children can be far more cognitively loose, inventively creative than people are later in life. The latest in this comes from Alison Gopnik's research which was reported at Time magazine (with a kind of weird headline). [This might be part of the reason that children are notoriously hard to trick with magic, at least compared to adults.]

And maybe this phenomenon (considered perhaps too broadly here but I can't resist) that our minds become more rigid as we learn, as we grow up, is contributing to the difficulty I have teaching evolution to undergraduates in my introductory biological anthropology course. After all, as the Time article says,
Their previous experience in the world, which tends to work in a single-cause-equals-single-effect way, hampered their ability to accept the unusual rules that activated the toy; they wanted to believe that it was activated either by a single color or by a combination of colors, but not both. “The training didn’t seem to give them a hint that the world might work in different ways,” says Gopnik, who published her work in the journal Cognition.
So what's next? I'll stop fantasizing about lost wisdom and, instead, I'll be assessing whether the students who've had their wisdom teeth removed, or never had them grow in the first place, are learning evolution better than the rest. Obviously. 

Friday, December 20, 2013

"Every trait is due to natural selection!"....often said, but is it true?

It is often said by people who claim to understand evolution that every trait is due to natural selection.  This is belief in a form of very strong determinism that reduces, in essence, to genetic determinism.  It's closely akin to the confident defense of the pop-culture concept of the 'selfish' gene against all challenges.  Put another way,  in such a view, natural selection is not a scientific statement about evidence, but an axiom--an assumption--that is used to make inference from data, but not something to be tested in itself.

For reasons we'll go into, it's not entirely clear where this view comes from, but it's often justified as a form of materialism, as if Genesis According to Darwin is true and therefore selection is the proper riposte to Genesis According to God.  But it's highly misplaced in science, and the assumption obscures an actual discussion.  Let's agree that if we'll stay within the confines of materialism--that is, no mysticism and that the laws of physical nature must  not just be consistent with, but must also ultimately explain, everything biological--we can examine the nature of strongly determinstic Darwinism.

So let's consider the proposition that every trait is due to natural selection.  We'll use an example.  First we need a trait.  Ok, here's a picture of my thumb (not used out of vanity over its undoubted beauty!).  Is 'it' a 'trait'?  If it is, of course, we can speak about 'its' evolution.  If it's not a trait, then what is it and how can we understand it?

Thumbs up...or angles out....or....?

On second thought, maybe the whole thumb is not a 'trait'.   Maybe it's the angle,  θ, the measure of the bend where the second phalanx starts.  Or is the trait that my thumb has a second phalanx?  Or that I can make that angle?  Or is the trait the length, x, of the second phalanx?  Or the angle between the thumb and the first finger?  How do we decide?  All of these traits or parts of traits have in some way evolved together, so it's hard to say when one aspect begins and another one ends, that is, what is the 'trait'.

But let's say we make our decision on that question.  Then, if whatever we decide our trait must, by the usual assumption, have evolved by natural selection, we want to be able to say what it evolved 'for'.  And to do that, we must show that the trait we're assuming resulted from natural selection somehow had direct fitness (survival or fertility) effects, because, since to selectionistic explanations chance is not an option, differential fitness is the mechanism by which natural selection works.  If our trait is θ, that means that if my ancestors had had an intrapollectial angle (pollex means thumb in Latin, and therefore using the word makes it 'science') that was--what?--greater than my θ, or was it less than my θ, or was it enough that it wasn't exactly my θ?, then they didn't have any kids and I wouldn't be here!

But wait!  What if the trait was the length of the distal pollectial segment, x, that mattered.  Those ancestors with more stubby thumb-ends are fossils without issue (that means, by the way, that when paleontologists dig them up they can't interpret what they were adapted for, since the death was because they weren't adaptive).  Or maybe those with gross thumbs whose last digit was a tad too long (how much is too much--one millimeter, say?) died out.  The trouble of course is that even my adaptive distant ancestors are dead, and how can we say whether they were 'fully' adaptive and died after having many kids, or were just caught by a lion when they wandered carelessly away from the campfire to take a pee one night (we don't need to consider whether, perhaps gender-related, the thumb trait was involved in that latter process).

Now given my important pollectial triangle (here we consider θ and x to have jointly been the critical 'trait', though what justification there is for that is an open issue), our task is to understand what natural selection molded it for.

The obvious thing is to look at what we actually do with our thumbs (that requires a triangular configuration like mine).   Most anthropologists will argue that our thumbs are for tool use--at least, it says that in textbooks about thumbs, so it must be true.  But I know that my deep ancestors didn't have pens and pencils or space-bars to tap, so it must have been for throwing stones in annual sporting events where the winner impressed the girls and, well, you know....

What about holding a rake in the fall when I clear my yard of leaves---it couldn't have been for that because my ancestors evolved in Africa where you don't have to rake leaves in the fall because it's tropical and there is no fall!  No, I have to think of uses that aren't just modern exploitations of a trait that was strongly selected in the past for something they did in the past.  This is a bit now-centered, because in the past the use of the traits they had then might not have been for what they did then, but what their ancestors did in their distant past.

Anyway, I suppose since the trait must have had important fitness-related function, if it is assumed to have evolved by natural selection, it may have had a role in sexual stimulation of some sort.  One can let one's imagination run wild, but we needn't go that far.  As I was saying, other than for modern uses, what I use my pollectial angle for is for getting itchy specks of dust out and sleep-grains of the corner of my eye.  Without that angle, θ, I wouldn't easily be able to do it.  Now on the dusty African savannah, when sharp-eyed spotting of  prey and aiming of spears or hunting-stones was vital, the eye-clearing use of thumbs is an obvious explanation.

There is the annoying little question of why not everyone's thumbs have exactly the same triangle--side length or angle.  If this is an adaptive trait formed by natural selection long ago, which it must have been since humans around the world have pollectial triangles (and so did Neandertals and even Denisovans!), then why is it still so variable?

Well, I'm getting tired of all this speculation.  This is especially unnerving because I can think of other aspects of thumbs that might be considered as traits, or the trait may be a complex of traits with their own individual selective reasons.  Or, really disturbing, these assembled aspects may have had different functions (that affected reproductive success) during the million years in which the trait(s) were adaptively evolving.

Now selectionist axioms don't provide room for probability in reproductive success.  That's why earlier I said that if my ancestors' value of θ was even a bit different from mine, then they must not have reproduced; if some tolerance was allowed, then fitness would be probabilistic, and that means chance, which is not allowed: the trait has to be functionally deterministic. That's because once you admit probabilities (genetic drift), you open the door to all sorts of less satisfying, less simple, and less clear-cut explanations--and Nature and the Times will shun your papers.  Part of the fear is that if one says a trait's presence is for 'random' reasons, it opens the door to creationism or, worse, lack of some explanation that's simple enough for undergraduates to understand or the research to be reported in the NY Times. It raises the specter of a 747 arising randomly out of a pile of scrap metal.

This is a silly non sequitur, since nobody (not even neutralists, who somehow can conceive of aspects of traits that arose for no adaptive reason at all) denies the role of various sorts of constraint, including classical natural selection, even when invoking genetic drift.  But it's just as silly to think that every tiny aspect of every trait has to be here because of specific natural selection in the usual sense.  Darwin rationalized various aspects of traits, such as correlations among them, basically as having developmental-constraint reasons and so on.  We know of such things in better molecular terms today.

More importantly, it is the definition of what counts as a 'trait' that we should be thinking more seriously about.  Organisms evolve as organisms, not just as sets of traits, and to the extent that a trait is in the eye of the definer, speculations about what it's 'for'  may also be just-so stories in the mind of the definer.  So is the use of selection as an axiom: if something (whatever that be) is assumed  to be here because of selection, then to say that it's here because of selection is a tautology.  The care one must take to avoid such tautological thinking has been known for many decades.  There are serious questions about evolution's mechanism that usually are swept under the rug because they point out inconvenient complexity that does not lead to convenient publishable answers. Who decides where a 'trait' s/he can define is or was a unitary phenomenon during its evolution?  And who decides how precise the hypothesized adaptation was?   And who decides how much of its variation may have been tolerated or even itself adaptive?

Trait micro-definitions, arbitrary post-hoc trait definition, and so on show by example how hard it is to legitimately decide what to include.  And if, as most of the evidence both theoretical and observational suggests, typical selective advantages are on the order of about one per thousand (you have 10001 kids with a good thumb-angle vs 1000 without such an angle), that is almost meaningless besides being literally impossible to prove.  It certainly means that traits with socially sensitive implications when interpreted in strong selectionist terms are, evolutionarily, essentially meaningless, as is the very notion that selection like that is a determinative 'force'.  Many such traits probably exist, and most traits may be like that, if we could even decide how to define them.  They should be deprived of their societal implications or value judgments, or much of the scientific surety with which the explanations are too-often couched.  Even mate-choice criteria, that could be very close to fitness, if the trait is used only now and then because there really wasn't much choice in human ancestral populations or kinship rules specified who you mated with, may mean little locally even if over long term the scenario is true.

The point about thumbs may seem like a kind of reductio ad absurdam, but is it?  Viewed from some time or vantage points, structures whose adaptive origins may seem obvious might be as problematic as my thumb from some other frames of reference.  For thousands of generations it could be that, say, the angle or size of the iliac crest would seem as trivial a 'trait' as my thumb, while today it seems fundamental to upright posture.

Fatigue wins....
I must confess that my patience is running low (that's one of my traits!), so I am simply ignoring the wrinkles in the thumb.  They may actually be the trait that evolved adaptively, though 'for' what is beyond me.  Probably I'm just tiring.  You can provide the explanation without my help, I'm sure.