Showing posts with label pseudogenes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pseudogenes. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

The genetics of olfaction -- is a rose a rose by any other nose?

Laura Spinney writes about the genetics of olfaction in The Independent this week, and about population variation in what we can smell.  The genetics of olfaction have been pretty well worked out; in fact, the 2004 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine went to Linda Buck and Richard Axel for this work.  But there is much still left to understand. 

Genes for olfactory receptors (ORs) comprise the largest gene family in the mammalian genome -- at about 900 genes and pseudogenes in humans, they make up approximately 3% of our total genome. On average, we've each got about 400 working olfactory receptor genes, and the rest have accumulated enough mutations to no longer be functional, and are now pseudogenes.  This is not quite accurate, because we are diploid so that we actually have about 800 OR genes, 2 copies of the 400.  Of the hundreds of these genes, many are polymorphically pseudogenes, meaning their sequence works in some copies in the population, but has been mutated out of function in others.

In addition, the copies we each have of each of our functional OR are themselves highly variable in their odorant binding pockets (the part of the receptor that binds to odorant molecules that float by in the nose).
"When I give talks, I always say that everybody in this room smells the world with a different set of receptors, and therefore it smells different to everybody," says Andreas Keller, a geneticist working at the Rockefeller University in New York City. He also suspects that every individual has at least one odorant he or she cannot detect at all – one specific anosmia, or olfactory "blind spot", which is inherited along with his or her olfactory apparatus.
Each olfactory receptor responds to several odorants.  But with so many genes, how on earth could we actually distinguish what we're smelling?  The answer is remarkable and one of the most interesting unsolved problems in genetics.  Our hundreds of OR genes are located in many different clusters of a few to hundreds of adjacent duplicate OR genes.  And we have two copies of each.  But in each individual olfactory neuron, only one of these hundreds of genes is expressed!  The other 799 genes, all over the genome, are inactive.

From Genetics and the
Logic of Evolution
,
Weiss and Buchanan, 2004
Further, neurons expressing a given OR are in some way guided by that choice to collect in OR-specific locations in the olfactory bulb of the brain.  That's what makes it possible for the brain to tally what specific receptors have been triggered.  That is, the binding of an odorant to its receptor triggers its perception in the brain.  The wiring pattern is to some extent, at least, conserved among individuals, so in that sense we may share not only the ability to identify, say, 'lemon', but to experience it in somewhat similar ways.

Most odor perception involves a combination of signals from a number of different receptors.  And, some of those receptors may be non-functioning pseudogenes in some people, and if the subset of pseudogenes differs, the odor perceived will be different.
That genetic variability is reflected in behavioural variability, as Keller, with colleague Leslie Vosshall and others, recently demonstrated when they asked 500 people to rate 66 odours for intensity and pleasantness. The responses covered the full range from intense to weak, and from pleasant to unpleasant, with most falling in the moderate range – a classic bell curve in each case.
There is also variation in how intensely people can smell.  Some people are born with no ability to smell, while others are acutely aware of odors.  This may have nothing to do with odorant receptors, but instead how efficiently the odorant signal is transmitted to the brain.

One of us (Ken) spent a sabbatical in England working with Manolis Dermitzakis at the Sanger genome institute outside of Cambridge, trying to find genomic DNA sequence 'signals' that might help explain the extensive monoallelic and monogenic expression of only one OR per olfactory neuron.  Unfortunately, the search was frustratingly unfruitful. In fact, earlier we had done a study in the Pennsylvania Amish, collaborating with one of the experts cited in the Spinney story to see if, in this classic founder-effect population, we could work out the genetics of the ability to identify specific odorants, for which the ability to smell seemed, in other studies, to be polymorphic.  We couldn't find any pattern, because essentially everyone could smell all the test odorants.

The unusual expression pattern of this huge gene family, and the bookkeeping by which its detection of complex odorants allows us to identify our surroundings with a great deal of reliability (and, much more so in other species like dogs, who use the same system) is one of the remarkable, and incompletely understood, facts of genetic life.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Genes playing possum!

A story by Gina Kolata in the NY Times reports a muscular disorder that is due to what was considerd a 'dead' gene, or 'junk' DNA.  A dead gene, usually called a pseudogene, is a DNA sequence derived from an incomplete copy of a functionally active gene, or a gene that was once actively used but whose transcription regulatory sequence mutated away.  Or a gene could suffer a mutation in its coding sequence that makes the resulting protein not work.

The smugness with which DNA sequence in between regular protein-coding genes was called 'junk' DNA is rapidly fading.  Much of our DNA has no known function, but even there we have evidence that there may be function--for example, some regions of such DNA have sequence that is conserved (basically the same) among species that haven't shared a common ancestor for many millions or more years.  If it had no function maintained by natural selection, why hasn't mutation simply erased the similarity among species of that sequence?

To find that a pseudogene region that was known to be transcribed into RNA can actually interfere with normal processes is interesting and biomedically important.  It's worthy of a story in the Times (and Kolata is a worthy person to write it) (see, we don't just criticize the popular science media!).

We can't make generalizations from this about 'junk' DNA however.  The degree to which a bit of non-coding DNA has some function, of some sort, is difficult to know simply because proving 'no' function is virtually impossible.  That's why evolutionary conservation is a persuasive indicator that something's still usefully active.

Francis Collins is quoted as saying that this is interesting and complex in its mechanism, which is not yet understood.  He rightly says that in genetics, whatever can go wrong will go wrong--a principle Ken called the Rusty Rule of life in his 1990 book on disease genes, because evolutionarily we know this had to be so, since mutation can strike anywhere in the genome.

There may be DNA with no function, not even spacing-function to keep other functional elements some proper distance apart.  Perhaps it could be called 'junk'.  But right now the problem we face in non-coding DNA is the opposite: there is so much of it, it's hard to understand how natural selection could be maintaining it.

When a sequence variant has very little function--and most of this DNA seems clearly in that category--then we expect genetic drift (chance) to determine how the frequency of the variant will change over time.  In that case, deep evolutionary conservation is not to be expected or at least should be less than that of really functional DNA.  But even saying 'less' is problematic, because we need a baseline for the rate at which variation will accumulate in truly nonfunctional DNA.

But if we can't be sure of what's really nonfunctional, where is our baseline?  We can try theory, try some experimental things (like watching bacteria over thousands of generations in a lab), but it's not easy to know.

Ironically, a common bit of DNA to use for that baseline is--you may have guessed it--pseudogenes!  Because a dead gene has no function!  Well, the Times example shows that some, at least, do have a function, and it is very possible that this disorder, though not lethal, could affect the reproductive success of those unfortunate enough to carry it.

Life is always playing tricks on it.  What you see may not be what you get.  Something may look pseudo, but only be playing possum.

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Come Together … Right Now … Over Teeth

I dare say that all paleontologists, including myself, drool over papers like this one recently published in PLoS Genetics, because, as the authors write, it “provides manifest evidence for the predictive power of Darwin’s theory."

Instead of looking at the genes behind new or modified existing traits, the authors looked at the genes for traits that have disappeared. Most lost or vanishing traits that come to mind are comprised of soft tissues that do not preserve well in the fossil record (e.g. cave fish eyes), but thanks to the steadfast properties of enamel, tooth loss and enamel loss can be examined both genetically and in the fossil record. That means the evolutionary scenarios for the evolution of enamel loss and tooth loss can be rendered in much higher resolution, if you will, than those for soft tissue traits.

Tubulidentata (aardvarks), Pholidota (pangolins), Cetacea (whales, porpoises, and dolphins), and Xenarthra (armadillos, sloths and anteaters) are four groups of mammals with toothless and/or enamelless taxa. They also have pretty decent fossil records, especially when it comes to teeth. What’s more, mutations in known mammalian genes (e.g. enamelin’s gene ENAM) that are involved in enamel formation are known to – wait for it – cause defects in enamel.

This is a perfect opportunity to bring fossils and DNA together.

Do these mammals in question show degeneration, like a pseudogene, at ENAM? Yes, various kinds.

Do the nature of those changes support the phylogenetic hypotheses made by comparative anatomy and the fossil record? Yes, mostly (e.g. enamel may have been lost independently in different armadillo lineages).

See for yourself here:

Molecular Decay of the Tooth Gene Enamelin (ENAM) Mirrors the Loss of Enamel in

the Fossil Record of Placental Mammals