Showing posts with label hyperbole. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hyperbole. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Microbiomes R Us -- another form of science marketing

The microbiome hits the big time 
A piece by food writer/journalist Michael Pollan, "Some of My Best Friends Are Germs", was the cover story of the New York Times magazine on Sunday.  Pollan says the interest he developed in fermented foods while he was writing his latest book -- beer, kimchi, cheeses -- naturally led into an interest in the fermentation that goes on in our large intestines with the help of resident microbes, and this led him to think generally about the interaction between microbes and us.

The current estimate is that microbial cells in and on our body outnumber our own cells ten to one.  The Human Microbiome Project, funded by the NIH, as yet another Big Science do it all and think about it later investment, was launched in 2008 with the goal of sequencing the microbes in the nasal passages, oral cavities, skin, and the gastrointestinal and urogenital tracts of a fairly small sample of men and women.  The project was completed last spring with sequences from samples from more than 240 people (completed means the authors can now go to the press and demand even more money because 'more research is needed' before we understand anything.....).

But, that's not the end.  In a drive to document the microbiome of America, The American Gut Project will sequence your microbiomes for $99.  It's an open source, open access project which allows participants to compare their data with data from people around the world. 

Why?  Because the microbiome is the new genetics.  Forget (our own) genes, the idea is that we are who we are, healthy or sick, because of the microbes we share our bodies with. Well, of course, it's the microbes' genes, so it's really just more genetics.  As Pollan puts it,
To the extent that we are bearers of genetic information, more than 99 percent of it is microbial. And it appears increasingly likely that this “second genome,” as it is sometimes called, exerts an influence on our health as great and possibly even greater than the genes we inherit from our parents.
Our microbiome may make us fat or keep us thin, predispose us to diabetes or heart disease or asthma and allergy. And, the microbiome apparently influences our immune system and trains it in how it responds to the world, and may be responsible for the increase in autoimmune diseases in the West. Indeed, Pollan writes of "an impoverished 'Westernized microbiome'" -- some researchers suggest that the microbiota in our gut should be restored to look more like the microbiomes of people who eat less processed food and take fewer antibiotics (and, by the way, are more likely to die early of infectious diseases than we are). 

But, happily for us, changing our second genome is going to be a lot easier than changing our first one.  We do it all the time, through our diet, the medicines we take, the people (and their microbes) we come into contact with.  Happily for Big Pharma and Big Food, once we know which microbes are best for us, they'll be able to sell you any number of products to reverse these changes and reduce your chances of getting all those diseases geneticists have been trying to find the causes of for so long.  You'll have personalized microbiomalgenomic medicine.  Enough to put another smile on Francis Collins' funds-securing face!

There has been a lot of talk lately about 'fecal transplants' which are just what they sound like -- the transfer of fecal bacteria from healthy people into the colons of unhealthy people, primarily people with Clostridium difficile infections, intestinal infections resistant to antibiotics.  And yes, there is a lot of information on the web for those who want to learn to do this kind of self-medicating at home.  

Overpromising yet?
Pollan (whose qualifcation for writing this piece is that he is a food journalist whose writing sells well) says a few times that people involved in researching the microbiome don't want to make the same mistake that geneticists did with the Human Genome Project, overpromising the extent to which their work will lead to the cure for everything that ails us.  But, if as Pollan claims, the microbiome community is actually talking about the Grand Unified Theory of Chronic Disease, there's apparently a fine line between hype and overpromising -- not to mention borrowing from physics' line that is used to justify Hadron.  And there are certainly plenty of 'probiotic' options in the grocery store these days, so someone's jumping the bandwagon. 

All satire aside, the point isn't that we doubt that there's a connection between microbes, health and disease.  Nor that there are indeed lots of nuggets of grain in the bin being described.  Instead, it's that these are early days yet, and the whole approach to this project is already sounding too reductionist for words.  Not only are microbiome researchers in danger of mimicking the genome project with overpromising to over-enumerate, but also by reducing everything to their favorite microbe (for 'microbe' we used to read 'gene'). The bugs for ability to play the bass or baseball, score well on IQ tests, or tolerate abuse with equanimity may be right around the corner.

Enough Just-So stories yet?
Indeed, the Just-So storytellers are already out in full force. Why are there complex carbohydrates in human breast milk, if babies can't digest them?  As Pollan puts it, "Evolutionary theory argues that every component of mother's milk should have some value to the developing baby or natural selection would have long ago discarded it as a waste of the mother's precious resources." So, it turns out they are there for a particular gut bacterium that breaks them down and uses them.  
“Mother’s milk, being the only mammalian food shaped by natural selection, is the Rosetta stone for all food,” says Bruce German, a food scientist at the University of California, Davis, who researches milk. “And what it’s telling us is that when natural selection creates a food, it is concerned not just with feeding the child but the child’s gut bugs too.”
And, we evolved this commensurate relationship with microbes because they evolve so much faster than we do, so can quickly evolve mechanisms to cope with new kinds of toxins in our environment and so forth.

And, the bacterium that causes ulcers and perhaps some stomach cancers, Helicobacter pylori, is an endangered species, writes Pollan.  But his informants tell him it shouldn't be.  H. pylori also has beneficial roles to play in our stomachs -- preventing acid reflux by regulating acidity, for example, which Pollan suggests they do to render the stomach inhospitable to competing microbes, or regulating levels of an appetite hormone -- and because they do these good things, they should be nurtured rather than killed off.  Why do they do both good and bad?  Well, they do the bad stuff when we're middle-aged or older, so Pollan's informant suggests "this microbe’s evolutionary role might be to help shuffle us off life’s stage once our childbearing years have passed."

Of course, among other curious aspects of this scenario, how something evolved to kill us off once we're no longer contributing genes to the human gene pool is not explained. In order for this to work, the fitness of the microbe that could do this would have to be increased by killing us, its host, and it doesn't work that way.

Stripping it down to the truth
Again, fine, it seems quite likely that our microbiome does make contributions to our health and disease.  That's interesting enough.  For various theoretical reasons, rapidly dividing microbes do present interesting evolutionary challenges, and there's no doubt that we, and our genomes, must respond successfully if we are to persist.  If infection, broadly defined, has early negative effects because of the host's genotype, then selection favoring the bacteria, and likewise selection favoring human resistance can both be strong.  Culture and climate and habits also contribute to this potentially very dynamic evolutionary mix.  Infectious diseases with strong effect on survival, like malaria and HIV and others have clearly demonstrable effects of this kind.

But that is not the same as invoking specific selective stories for complex, ephemeral, varying fluxes of bacteria, which must coexist as well as keep a host alive so they can stay alive.  It's not the same as inventing pat, closed Just-So stories about how this or that effect must have evolved, and it involves no subtleties that we know are applicable, including the range and mobility of humans, modes of transmission,  population size and so on.  We have had a difficult time, and often unsuccessful, in working out clear-cut examples of natural selection at work in humans, though our evolved defenses against malaria (which is not caused by bacteria but involve many relevant evolutionary issues) may be the best one. 

So why can't researchers, writers, the rest of us just concentrate on figuring out how and when microbes are harmful or beneficial, without the hyperbole, the suggestion that microbes now do everything that genes did not long ago, and the made-up stories about how this all evolved? 

This whole microbiome thing needs to slow down and let the science catch up.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

The $140 fix

In his State of the Union address to congress on Feb 12, President Obama laid out many ambitions for his next term.  It was a speech to the country and to Congress, and he stated many things he wanted to use the government for, in particular, goosing up the economy in various ways.

Like other  Presidents before him, and perhaps as is necessary given the complexity of his job and the topics he must deal with, Obama relies on lines and catch-phrases and selected data that he's been fed by advisers.  Often, as here, they represent vested interests within the Federal government.  For example, the Education secretary is bound to recommend this or that specific thing to fix our education problems.  The Energy department will recommend equally pressing needs, as will Defense and so on.

One needs to beware of the selectivity and promotional nature of factoids being cited, so as to at least be savvy about what they mean and why they're being cited--and of course to be aware that they are advocacy.  The President can only say, marionette-like, what he's told by people whose judgment he trusts, but they often do the same, passing things down the line to the primary advocates.  Just as lobbyists do provide expertise, along with their advocacy, advocacy isn't entirely self-serving.  But it can come pretty close and in a sense it's the President's, Congress's, and our responsibility to make the judgments about what is being said and what we believe are important.

Must everything we do be crass and venal?
In this context, Obama stated that the effort to 'map' the human genome has 'returned' $140 for every dollar ("--every dollar") that was spent on it.  How great!  But what does that suggest in a not very subtle way? That the science investment has value because it is good for business.  If that's the case, and apparently a great many people feel that it is, why not call it business socialism?  Or a welfare system for businesses and universities?

NIH isn't unique in playing the economy card, as well as the 'you will never get sick if you give us funds' card (and Obama repeated things NIH or others had told him along those lines, too).  It's how our system is constructed, perhaps.

Whether, when, or to what extent investment in NIH leads to a fully functional immortality is separate from the justification of funding on the grounds that it's good for business.  Obama isn't qualified to discuss whether to 'map' the human genome is the best or even a good way to remove disease from the face of the earth.  A State of the Union address may not be the place for subtle discourse.  But if we are just going to justify it on business grounds, we might as well not worry about whether, say, billions of dollars are spent on  projects that don't generate a single result, or projects that use mouse models that are totally inappropriate, or studies that grow ever larger when we know they'll find ever tinier effects, or projects that grow ever-larger research empires at the expense of intellectual freedom and the support of young scientists who could, with different distribution of resources, perhaps think more freely and have an even better chance of making discoveries that, yes, were good for the economy.

Our society perhaps simply can't be made to temper its exaggerations in support of vested interests, but we think that's a shame.  It systematically replaces substance with label, and numbs us from critical thinking.  If every word in our language must be a superlative, we'll all end up in semantic wonderland, like Lake Woebegon, all above average.

Monday, July 2, 2012

The mouse that roared, or the lion that peeped?

The Mouse that Roared was a funny comedy film, decades ago, about a little Alpine principality (the Duchy of Grand Fenwick) that managed to bring the US to its knees, to win major concessions.  The idea was to declare war on us, to lose, and then be the beneficiary of all the largesse we dump on those we defeat.

In science as in other areas of human endeavor, especially in a society slavishly obsessed with the 'business model' and 'competitiveness' and the bottom line--even in universities, we want to get the most bang for the buck as this little mouse of a country did by roaring at the huge US.  Science as it is practiced today raises some relevant issues.


The other day we criticized a very big study about calcium intake and heart disease risk, and it was but one of many critiques we have made again and again (and again) here on MT.  Our point was that sloppy designs and non-definitive results, that have to be repeated again and again (and again) with ever larger scales and for ever larger budgets, are becoming more of the rule than the exception.

In our areas of (we hope) knowledge, we blog away at the practice of ever increased scale for ever diminished payoff.  Examples are massive GWAS to find hundreds of miniscule, ephemeral possibly-causal genetic effects.  Despite fervent denials and claims of success, that's what's afoot in biomedical and other sciences.  It's the way we build careers, maintain labs and reputations, and earn our nice academic salaries.

But that is not the same as roaring lions of discovery.  Real progress.  We need ever larger, ever repeated studies because what we're trying to find are unclear, non-definitive, or (generally) minor effects.  It is more like fiscal lions generating peeps of results (but then roaring about them as if they were lions).

This kind of hyperbole is in the science news every day.  Indeed, the fact that there is a science news is part of the story, because the news outlets need to sell and the news needs stories, and investigators need the publicity to get their grants and make their careers, so we have a positive-feedback system where the big begets bigger, and the brag begets bragger.  We have come to something ColdWar-like: Mutually Assured Dependence.

As in the other day's post's example, larger and larger studies are needed if the effects we want to find are smaller and smaller.  And that also generally means that they are part of complex interactions in multi-factorial causal systems.  A small cause's effect depends on the other causes present or not present.  Even a cause that's always present, but is small, requires large studies to detect.

By contrast, truly major causes can be detected, replicably and reliably by small studies, that don't cost that much money and don't have to be endlessly repeated.  They are the mice that roar.  The late curmudgeonly David Horrobin said something to the effect that if you can't find it in samples of 30, it's not worth finding.  That's an exaggeration....but how much of one?

But our culture today is about spawning nearly mute lions.  We harp on this because lots of your money is paying for this kind of research.  Instead, we should be able to  provide smaller funding to more people, hoping somebody will make lucky or insightful discoveries, or being less socialistic, we could really pour funds at problems that really are genetic or more clearly addressable with accountable impact in the case of  public health or evolutionary science.  Maybe truly genetic diseases could be prevented or cured more effectively and more quickly if we did that.

Nothing's perfect.  First, pouring money into what should be soluble problems could be like the War on Cancer and other government allotments:  There may only be so many good researchers, and they may already be funded, for these problems.  And, as is manifestly clear, anytime there is a pot of dough, the hogs rush frantically to the trough so one would have to have strong constraints so the funds don't get divided up among a crowd of claimants generating chaff.  In fact, this is how the system largely works now, with me-too being a major modus operandi. And, ironically, those who would rail against socializing funding (equalizing distribution, etc.) may not realize that to a great extent that is what our system currently does.  It's how all the med schools keep their research factories in operation 24/7--by investigators flocking to wherever the funds are, inventing whatever rationales for their own ideas that we can think of.  In a way, because it is also intensely competitive, it is a form of capitalistic socialism, a strange beast!

Instead, we build empires of hoarse lions, omitting the potentially much more cost-effective mice who, like humble miners' canaries, could lead us out of the most troubling problems we face.