Showing posts with label Penn State. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Penn State. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

The hammer falls; now let's do some academic reform to show we've learned

The Joe Paterno statue is down, and the NCAA has hammered Penn State because of Joe's and the University's inaction at a repeat child abuser who liked the cozy showers of our Athletic Department.  It's not fair in lots of ways, but life is that way. The University didn't see to business properly, and a number of boys were seriously harmed--even if this had nothing to do with the athletes or the rest of the university.

But the memory of Joe Paterno, the rightfully legendary coach, will now be in disgrace for a fault that will overshadow his accomplishments.  Taking away his victory total is a ridiculous part of the punishment because it's wholly unrelated to the failings. But there were certainly real faults--there was clearly too much power given to athletics and too much idolization of the coach, too much brand-consciousness and risk aversion.  Keep anything negative quiet!

So Paterno's statue, which really should never have been put up while he was still active, is gone.  In fact, as most of us here knew, he had outlived his glory days before the main events that caused all this.  Had he retired at age 70 or so, when his coaching and recruiting skills and involvement were waning, and there was a lot of sentiment for him to become a senior statesman, this wouldn't have happened.

Of course, it did happen, and we pay the price.  So what do we do?  Our new administration has been saying the university will re-balance 'academics' with athletics.  Maybe the NCAA's sanctions will force us to actually do something to match those words--which, otherwise, will just be more cotton-candy from the spin machine that is in full gear trying to do just what got us into trouble: damage control.

Now that we will have a limited-talent football team for several years, perhaps we can really take our academic responsibilities seriously.  There might be, say, 50,000 fewer people at our down-graded football games.  Maybe some of the students just won't bother to go.  This should be seen as an opportunity.

We should raise the standards for student admissions, to attract here students who actually want to study and learn something; there might not be be nearly as many as we have here now, because this won't just be a 4-year party & football attraction.  Maybe they'll actually go to class (sober, at least more of the time), and classes will be smaller.  This will surprise them, since suddenly their work will be under scrutiny....but they'll also get more actual faculty attention than they can now.  Which is what they're paying for.

We should raise the standards for earning high grades, retention, and passing courses.  Reduce the subtle pressure on faculty to be entertainers, or to retain students who don't measure up, freeing those students to transfer and save on the cost of our very high tuition and go somewhere more suited to their abilities and interests--and enabling us to provide a better product to those many very fine students here who deserve that.  More homework, no graduation without basic skills compatible with a major university education.  Raise what it means to have earned a Penn State degree.

The sexual abuse scandal was dreadful, but its having been bottled up reflected a much broader pattern of image ('brand') protection, and looking the other way from serious problems, hoping they'll just go away has become a widespread kind of institutional reflex.  It's about image and revenue--and Penn State is not the only one at this game!

There is a national problem in higher education (not to mention K-12), in which universities are processing their 'student customers' in an exploitative way for their tuition that is not so different from how we exploit 'student athletes' for ticket and TV money (except Penn State and Joe Paterno insisted that the 'student-athletes' actually go to class!).

We can perhaps take some leadership nationally now that even if we wanted to remain obsessed with sports, we won't be able to.  We'll have to find some other way to contribute in a worthy way to society.  Why not start by giving our students a much better education, when they're no longer so distracted by football?

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Penn State: just another pedophilia scandal

Here's an interesting piece from The Atlantic from July 17.  "Could the Penn State Abuse Scandal Happen Anyplace Else?  Definitely."  It's an interview with Chris Gavagan who was involved in making a documentary of sexual abuse in sports called "Coached into Silence" and his answer is a resounding yes.  What happened here at Penn State was a classic case of pedophilia, the enabling of pedophilia, and the covering up of pedophilia to protect the institution and the people who should have been protecting the kids.  Nothing unique here.

The relevance to MT, besides that we live and work here, is that more and more is being published to document the high prevalence of pedophilia, including stories about its purported prevalence in other athletic programs.  If a high fraction, like 1 in 4 or 6, of children experience some sort of sexual abuse at the hands of adults, then not only do we have a social problem, but we have to re-think some of the commonly held views about a central area of biology: sex, and its relation to gender.

We've posted on this before.  Sex in terms of chromosome number (XX and XY) varies, with a non-trivial fraction of the population having some different number of X and/or Y chromosomes.  Or, they have mutational variants in their chromosomes that lead to unusual physical or reproductive traits.  While most people are XX or XY and most have the genital and other bodily manifestations associated with the normal genotypes, there is variation and whether or what aspects one wishes to characterize as, for example, 'disease' is somewhat subjective.  An evolutionary viewpoint would say that if the variant prevented successful reproduction it was dysfunctional or, in our cultural terms, 'disease'.

But that's not so clear, because many people have normal appearing chromosomes and normal appearing plumbing but bear no children despite having normal heterosexual relations.  How do we characterize that?  Here we tend to assume something psychological or cultural, and most of the time we'll allow it to be 'normal'.  You are not 'diseased' if you stay single, marry but choose not to reproduce (or simply don't end up having children despite trying), or become a nun or priest.  Or your tendency to honor monogamy, and so on.

Or, we have reasons in some instances to say that you have a physiological 'problem' or 'anomaly', that affects your sexual preference, behavior type ('gay' personality), or you look unusual for your sex, and so on.  This will be attributed largely to your genes, which then could be argued to mean that you may have the plumbing but you really aren't 'male' or 'female'.

Then some would argue that for cultural or physiological reasons you are of a normal 'sex' but a different-from-typical 'gender'.  Your behavior makes you act differently than you would for someone of your sex. Homosexuality would be one such variant.  But stereotypical homosexual behaviors--call them gender behaviors if you will--are not always associated with homosexuality.  Clearly there is variation and it's far from dichotomous.  There is not just one set of two distinct genders, and what one wishes to call abnormal or 'diseased' is subjective to a great extent.

Pedophilia seems to be an example.  Pedophiles have normal plumbing, are not gay, but prey on children (sometimes same-sex and sometimes opposite sex).  The 'ped' part is what's different and doesn't put you in one of the other classes--it seems to be a class of its own.  Psychologists apparently find that this is as ingrained as sexual preference, and is resistant to attempts to change it.  It is, somehow, born of the person's 'genes' or their interaction with early environments in unclear but clearly complex ways.

Now, if pedophiles are so common that 1/4 of all children experience their assault, clearly most pedophiles also marry and reproduce.  So are they 'diseased' in ways other than by social definition?  And, yes, pedophilia is an entry in the DSM (the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders).

This is a legitimate question since the age of 'consent' varies greatly among human cultures.  In turn that means that what we've been treating as a rare disorder is part of a continuum of variation that's not so rare at all.

What this would imply both about the biology of sex and gender, and about its evolution, is that we've been far oversimplifying the reality.  As is our usual wont, here we'll point out that with such complex and gradual variation, there won't likely be a single gene 'for' the trait, like pedophilia, nor a variant that isn't also found in 'normal' people.  It's an aggregate genotypic effect, of variants at many genes, interacting with environments--even if the result, like pedophilia, is built-in to the person when s/he is an adult.

So triggered by this scandal here at Penn State, and the facts it is evoking nationwide (along with the prior stimulus of the Catholic church and scout problems), this should force biologists to think more about the nature of sex and gender--so much at the heart of successful reproduction in a species, and at the same time, so variable.

Friday, July 13, 2012

Who pruned the Prunus?

We're writing as members of the Penn State community, which as about everyone knows by now has been shaken by a scandal because of a prominent member of our athletic department who turned out to be a serial child molester.

Now, a specially commissioned report on what happened, chaired by Louis Freeh, the FBI's former Director, has been released.  There have been prior leaks,  plus other available testimony, about how reports of sightings of the molester at work were, or weren't, properly dealt with.

Penn State as a whole has been taking the rap for this, as if one rogue in the way-beyond-control Athletic Department represented how the rest of us behave.  In relation to child molestation, abuses by one isolated individual in our isolated Athletic Department facilities (far on the edge of campus) aside, the rest of the faculty are truly innocent.

But the University as a whole?  That's a different story!

The fall of the poor cherry tree (genus Prunus)
George Washington, our country's founding idol, is said to have been truly an honest person. As a child, he has been said to have been so honest that when his father confronted him about a cherry tree that had been chopped down on their property, little Georgie said "I cannot tell a lie, father, you know I cannot tell a lie! I did cut it with my little hatchet.''  We don't know if he was taken to the woodshed by his father, in reward for his valiant confession.

This is relevant because it reflects something about our society that isn't as savory as our first President's forthcoming nature.  As the Freeh report loomed, everybody who could be, should be or anticipated being named in the report has been manoevering the spin-apparatus to make sure nobody thinks they knew anything or failed to act properly.  Our former President and his lawyers are making sure we all know he didn't know any more than a newborn babe, despite clear record, even before the report was released, that something of some sort was known to him.

Other former administrators, indicted for perjury, are making sure we all know that they would never, ever look the other way at serious offenses like child abuse.  And how could you even think that the trustees and university lawyers knew anything!

The university has been offering pre-emptively consoling meetings with victims and the solace of monetary compensation for stresses they may have experienced because somebody (else) may have done something they shouldn't (because the University wouldn't tolerate such antics!).

We're even seen pre-emptive imaging-preserving manoevering by the deceased.  Joe Paterno can't speak for himself, but his family are making moves and publicity bleats to ensure us that he would never have looked the other way.  How his family would know about something they didn't witness is not clear, unless they've been at some unpublicized seances.

The Freeh report, as neutral before-hand as one can ask, we think, sees it differently:  There was a cherry tree here,  it did get chopped down, and the report identifies who did it but tried to wriggle out of responsibility.

Like one, like all: see no evil, do no evil
It's not just here at this particular university.  It's become the American way:  nobody seems to be guilty of anything, ever.  From disingenuous spinning, and in this case pre-spin-spinning, including pervasive advertising and image management, from individual to organization, this is a nation of angels!

We occasionally hear a myth that confession is good for the soul.  Not many, say like the person we'll not name in this image (whom some might assume has a soul), are able to say even if reluctantly as this guy seems perhaps to be thinking about saying,  "Well, OK, I must confess..."


If confession is good for the soul, our good souls apparently don't feel they need it.

Sadly, the denouement may not leave everyone unbesmirched.  The administrators being fingered have generally lived highly honorable and decent lives, as officials, President, and Coach.  Their achievements need to be recognized as we keep all of this in balance.  We all make mistakes (though we'll rarely admit it!).

But the underlying problem, that of excessive attention to image and 'brand, over substance, is more serious and was pervasive around here--we have been noting it for years, unrelated to anything to do with the child-abuse case.

While it's too bad to be administered by so obsessively risk-averse an attitude, that it won't make reforms, it's not unique to Penn State. There is, for example, a well-documented national malaise in higher education that nobody dares address directly, essentially because to do anything about it we'd all have to change our ways, and tuition income could be jeopardized.  Many of a school's prominent faculty are not teaching as much as students paying tuition or their parents may have expected from the recruiting brochures they get.  Our stress on research is arguably far out of proportion given its actual contribution to our overall responsibility to the public we serve.  We are looking the other way at a different kind of abuse, student-abuse: we are tacitly pressured to entertain, and are not providing rigorous enough education nor one that--in the market mentality we think makes us so smart and insightful about how to do things--is tied to the product we are 'selling'.  We admit students many of whom are not prepared for, able, or interested in high-level academic learning (and the work that is required by them--and us, to bring it off).  We boast that bowl wins--sports--increase admission applications as if that's a good reason to apply here (but it's good for business!).  We talk about 'student-athletes' (a legalism used strictly to avoid problems with how we exploit them), but not about 'student-customers'.

The lowered academic standards is a national problem; administrators from department Heads to Deans to the main office, know the situation very well, yet no serious action seems to be taking place.  We talk the 'academics' talk but we don't walk the walk.  Institutions daren't jeopardize their image,  brand,  athletic department income, nor lose faculty to other institutions if we insisted on fulfilling a more responsive mission.

It's worse and more general than just that, too.  The finger of responsibility, in our society at large, never points to many who deserve it and are at the core of our disingenuousness: the advertising industry, scandal and hype-hungry media, PR firms, lawyers, and politicians who will sell whatever they can gain by selling.  We tolerate this, so we're all in it together.

This is relevant because SanduskyGate was just one manifestation of the consequences of this attitude that happened to escape into the public eye.  Indeed, even now it seems likely, but unfortunate, that we'll encyst SanduskyGate as if it were an isolated problem, to protect the rest of the university--and to avoid having to address the deeper problem of which this was but a sorry instance.   The problem of risk aversion in the face of real problems was something many of us here have been pointing out over the years of our recent administration's tenure. 

This protective, restricted-acknowledgment attitude is going to be reinforced as trials and more expensive PR brand control seem inevitable.  We'll all be making sure that this was done by somebody else, and that you realize we have halos and gossamer wings.  Just like George Washington.

The only thing is, the story of Georgie's confession isn't true.

Friday, November 11, 2011

The light shines

Just 2 days ago we posted a lament about our university, Penn State.  We've been beset by a scandal of large proportions, in which brand-protection by safe administrators allowed unsafe juveniles to be branded for life by experiences inflicted on them by a very prominent member of our football coaching staff, apparently over many years.

The famous, even revered head coach Joe Paterno, and our President (along with some others) were summarily fired by our Board of Trustees, when they learned of this.  Then, protecting the brand, and the iconic JoePa, some of our dregs (every university has dregs) rowdied in the streets, adding a new ugliness.

But Penn Staters have long been known for high levels of social activism, and the top-enders here recognized the need to go beyond football and coaches when it comes to something much more important, in this case, pedophilia.

Our best are already experienced and organized for doing good things, and in almost no time plans were made for ways to honor the victims, and remember this is not about football.  They organized a candle-light vigil in respect for and for protection of abused children.  Thousands of blue t-shirts were made, using the color already designated for such anti-abuse activities, and thousands--many thousands--of our students assembled on the lawn in front of the President's office.

However, hundreds of thousands of the Penn State family don't live here.  Do they care?  Take a look at this immediate response on the web and even more poignantly, look at this on YouTube.

And then a pep rally for the game was cancelled and the candle-light vigil drew an estimated 10,000 (of our best) students:


So, while the media do their job and find the many more shoes that are clearly likely to drop,  to reveal how much deeper the cover-up by the University and Second Mile were, a Phoenix of good may come of this.   We've lost our legendary coach and our public-face President, which seemed like a heavy blow, but by the time the stories are all out, perhaps nobody will be left to regret that.  Now Penn State needs to reform, regroup, reinvigorate ourselves as a serious university that happens to have a football team.  What a good example and pace we could set, if the moment is taken at its current flood!

Maybe we could start by not admitting any more goons, and reduce our class size so we could give the deserved attention to the students who actually want to be here to learn something.

Wednesday, November 9, 2011

What is Penn State?

Dear MT readers:
We have both been here at Penn State University for 26 years.  When we got here, Joe Paterno had already become legendary and had been our football coach for nearly 20 years.  He had already long and publicly stood for doing the right thing.  Students that do not cheat, that honor themselves and the university, and that graduate, even if not all in high-pressure majors.  In many, many ways that ideal is just what he achieved, and with few precedents anywhere in the United States.

Legions of Penn State students (and faculty) have acted with pride and dignity, and for things that were right, and just. Our graduates were recently shown to be among the most active in service to their communities, and the like.

But it's well known, and sad, that another major part of our reputation, and what draws too many students here, are sports well out of control, and a culture of riotous drunken behavior. 

That is one of a number of issues that Penn State did not confront.  It has been an insular university, where 'loyalty' means promoting from within, and unfortunately, circling the wagons when it comes to controversy.  Loyalty to our image--our 'brand'--has taken far too much precedence when it comes to dealing with things like the drinking party culture, the excessive stress on sports and similarly superficial things, and the scandal that is now engulfing us.  Pleasing undergraduate students and a fine Nittany Nation image, have taken precedence over academic rigor.

This is not just about hypocritical judgments in hind-sight on our part.  Probably there are more facts to emerge, and it seems unlikely that they will be in any way exculpatory.  Those in charge went through a few of the motions, but did not press to see that reports of sexual abuse were followed up.  More probably knew more, long ago even, about the sex abuse than has come to light so far.  Who knows--perhaps innocently, conveniently, administrators just hoped it would go away.  Perhaps no one wanted, or dared, to be the one who brought negative light on 'dear old State'.

Our President was always someone for whom it seemed that appearance and spin consistently took precedence over substance.  He was very good for us in many ways, raised a lot money and built many buildings.  But one can see how his over-riding need for smiling before cameras is what led in many ways to where we are now.  Had he been a person more about substance than appearance, even a whiff of child abuse would have, or should have, led to action.  Instead, a mentality of covering up rather than taking stands on difficult issues, of which there are many examples, allowed things to build to a point when they could no longer be contained.  We are, properly, paying the price for that today.

On the other hand, we can assure any MT readers who many not know it, that there are many, many very fine, good, intelligent, delightful, thoughtful and decent people here--among our students, our faculty, and our staff.  We hope this will not be overlooked.

We are embarrassed, but more importantly, we are saddened for the boys who were abused, by a person of power in the storied Penn State football program.  The abuses went on for so long, many here on campus, that many of these boys are now men.  The fact of their pain should not be forgotten.

But we will move onward.  Hopefully, a new administration will pay more attention to the real issues facing universities, ours as well as others, and less to football, partying, and photo-ops. 

It is a moment, and we hope we'll seize it!

We owe that to our many, many very fine, good, intelligent, delightful, thoughtful and decent people here--among our students, our faculty, and our staff.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

One climate getting warmer, the other cooler

I read in our Penn State student newspaper that our internal investigation of the 'Climategate' emails is under way, and properly being kept totally confidential so hearsay and rumor don't sully anyone's reputation (one of our meteorology faculty is a major correspondent in the emails).

The good news out of Copenhagen, if there will actually be any, is that those who defend the idea of global warming are warming to the task of defending the cold shower that the hijacked emails were used to put on the idea that we're mucking about with our childrens' climatic future.

The scientists at the meeting are not circling their wagons and just defending the questionable-sounding emails or the Fox 'News' style reactionary assault. They're on the proactive side, presenting in clear and strong terms the wealth of evidence, none of it dependent on the emails' content, for global change.

Hopefully, they'll replace the disappearing glaciers with a glacial chill put on the muckrakers, regardless of whether those particular guys acted questionably or not.