Saturday, November 21, 2026

To Debate the Imagined Past, or Not to Debate the Imagined Past?

There's a new paper in the Journal of Human Evolution that is the continuation, and further-building-up, of an argument that male-male contest competition for sex explains male violence and other behaviors, as well as many anatomical features. 

I had already seen the new paper, thanks to a Google alert that told me my work was cited in it. And I had already assigned it in one of the (three) classes* that I'm teaching this semester by the time a journalist reached out to me, asking me if I'd be interested in reading it and talking to her about it. 

Since I was cited and since I was already going to read it, I said sure. I'm not promoting my book just yet and I really don't want to argue about peoples' work through a third party, but I figured I could still, maybe, have something valuable to say.

So, we scheduled a zoom and then time lapsed between her email and our zoom, during which I read the paper. That's when I saw that, despite it citing mine, it was not actually in conversation with mine and so I immediately regretted the commitment to talk. It's one thing to discuss peoples' work through a journalist, but it's another to do so about ideas that do not reckon with yours. 

You don't even have to read the entire thing to see what I mean. Just go to the paper. Search for Dunsworth. Find the three in-text citations to my 2020 paper and see that the first acknowledges the challenge, the second is about the sexual selection narrative perpetuating sexism and patriarchy, and the third... the third is the last one and purports to actually acknowledge the point of my paper, but... does not. Here's the screengrab:


Here's the text, copy-pasted for easier reading:

Another possibility is that some of men’s traits represent developmental byproducts of male body size or testosterone levels. Strength increases with body mass and height (Balogun et al., 1991), for example, although other male traits are not known to relate to body size (e.g., beards) or relate only weakly (e.g., voice pitch; Pisanski et al., 2014). However, even traits that are correlated with size are far more sexually dimorphic than would be predicted from sex differences in size alone (Claes et al., 2012; Puts et al., 2012b; Zaidi et al., 2019). Similarly, hormones such as testosterone play important roles in the development of male-typical traits, so one might conjecture that these traits are merely developmental side effects of gonadal hormones (e.g., Dunsworth, 2020). This viewpoint confuses proximate and ultimate explanation, leaving unresolved the question of why humans have evolved to respond to testosterone by growing facial hair and longer vocal folds or to estradiol by arresting long bone growth, for example (Galipaud and Kokko, 2020, Font and Carazo, 2021a). Why instead, do we not respond to testosterone by growing antlers, as in red deer (Suttie et al., 1995), or canines, as in many other primates (Van Wagenen and Hurme, 1950)? Why does testosterone not increase paternal investment, as in the California mouse (Peromyscus californicus) (Gleason and Marler, 2013), rather than having the opposite effect, as it does in many vertebrates, apparently including humans (Kuzawa et al., 2009)? Clearly, different species, even closely related ones, can evolve quite different responses to the same hormones. An evolutionary history of male contests explains why, in humans, a particular constellation of sexually dimorphic traits, including large size, may be developmentally linked to testosterone and to each other (Hill et al., 2017; Muller, 2017).

From there, you would assume Dunsworth 2020 is about testosterone. It is not. It mentions androgens a few times but never testosterone and is about estrogen. Go ahead and search the paper to see for yourself. As you do, you might take-in the point of it, which is never taken seriously by Puts and Koohgard. Instead, they cite a paper that said mine is confused and suggest that my perspective is lacking because it did not answer all those questions about testosterone.  If you'd rather read a quick distillation of my paper, instead of the whole thing, here you go: https://ecodevoevo.blogspot.com/2026/02/whats-true-about-evolution-of-mens.html

To start our interview, I asked the journalist why she wanted to talk to me and she said exactly what I thought she would, "Because they cite your paper on testosterone..."

After I explained how awkward it was to be talking to a journalist about a paper that doesn't take yours seriously, I did a little bit anyway... 

**

Holly Dunsworth, a biological anthropologist at the University of Rhode Island, sees Puts and Koohgard’s paper as part of a wider trend of debating unknowable evolutionary causes. She questions the value of that work, while stopping short of saying it has none. 

Dunsworth said evolution is true but argued that the specific evolutionary causes of ancestral behaviors and traits can’t be known. “We have no systematic way of testing [Puts and Koohgard’s] idea against alternatives and for choosing the one that is closest to the truth,” she said. After years of study, Dunsworth is “very confident about what we don’t know and what we can’t know” — she has laid out her view in a book due out in June.

While anthropologists including Hames believe in uniformitarianism — a principle centered on the idea that the present is the key to the past — Dunsworth argues that knowing how evolution works does not mean we can identify the specific causes of evolutionary changes in the past. In her view, debating the details of Puts and Koohgard’s theory risks distracting from that fundamental uncertainty. She declined to offer alternative explanations, saying that would mean entering a debate “that will always be a debate.” 

“It’s always about who will win, whose argument is most preferred by most people, and sounds the most like common sense,” Dunsworth said. “That’s not what I’m interested in participating in.” 

**

If you read any of my journey through the book Sapiens here this year, then the ideas may not be surprising, but it may be surprising to see them out in the wild, off this blog, mixing with others.

Because I had to tell her why I was so certain about uncertainty--all the work I just put into writing my upcoming book--then I had to mention my upcoming book. If you are at all interested in what I had to say in the Big Think piece, then you will probably like my book which is entirely about all that. 

It was a nice surprise to see that she found my book and linked to the preorder page! Since she did, then I guess I should too...

US: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/725877/the-myth-of-mankind-by-holly-dunsworth/ 

UK (the cover is great, but not yet posted): https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/455953/the-myth-of-mankind-by-dunsworth-holly/9780241633427

Canada: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.ca/books/725877/the-myth-of-mankind-by-holly-dunsworth/9780593654675


*The class is Anthropology 399: Sex and Reproduction in Our Species. 

Here is the course description: 

What does evolution have to do with sexual behavior, gender, and patriarchy? Put another way, are we basically gorillas or not? Towards an answer, in this course we will investigate the inter-related biological, behavioral, and sociocultural facets of human sexual and reproductive behavior. What exactly about human reproduction is similar to other organisms and what is different? What are the consequences of those similarities and differences, in our lives? How do cultural concepts (especially those of traditional evolutionary science) of sex, sexuality, and gender help or hinder our understanding of human nature? These concepts are dominated by theory in evolutionary psychology, but is evolutionary psychology possible? These and many other questions will be raised and addressed in this course which requires deep reading, as well as active engagement in the classroom based on that scholarly preparation outside of class. Class time will be spent on a mix of informed discussion, activities, and lectures. Performing excellent scholarship, based on high level critical thinking and information literacy which is transferrable across disciplines, is one goal of this course. 

Here is the reading list (which doesn't include papers I put into lectures, like Patty Gowaty's, Wood and Eagly's, or Zachary DuBois and Heather Shattuck-Heidorn's):

Buss, David. 1985. Human Mate Selection. American Scientist 73: 47-51

Buss, David. 1989. Sex differences in human mate preferences: Evolutionary hypotheses tested in 37 cultures. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 12, 1-49

de Waal, Frans. 2022. Different: Gender Through the Eyes of a Primatologist. Norton (Introduction, pages 1-18; Chapter 1, pages 19-37—Toys are Us: How Boys, Girls, and Other Primates Play; Chapter 2, pages 38-60—Gender: Identity and Self-Socialization)

Dunsworth, Holly and Anne Buchanan, “Sex Makes Babies,” Aeon, August 9 2017, https://aeon.co/essays/i-think-i-know-where-babies-come-from-therefore-i-am-human

Dunsworth, Holly, “Do animals know where babies come from?” Scientific American 314, no. 1(2016): 66-69.

Dunsworth, Holly M. “Expanding the evolutionary explanations for sex differences in the human skeleton,” Evolutionary Anthropology 29, no. 3 (2020):108–116.

DuVal, Emily H., et al., “Inferred Attractiveness: A generalized mechanism for sexual selection that can maintain variation in traits and preferences over time. PLoS Biol 21, no. 10(2023): e3002269

Fausto-Sterling Anne. 2020. Sexing the Body. Basic (Chapter 10, pages 268-313—A Sea of Gender)

Fausto-Sterling, A. 2019. Gender/Sex, Sexual Orientation, and Identity Are in the Body: How Did They Get There? J Sex Res 56(4-5):529-555.

Fuentes, Agustín. 2020. Searching for the “Roots” of Masculinity in Primates and the Human Evolutionary Past. Current Anthropology 62(suppl 23): S13-S25.

Guarino, Ben. "Women rate the strongest men as the most attractive, study finds". Washington Post. (Plus, the original research article, which students find themselves.)

Harari, Yuval. 2015. Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind. Harper (Chapter 8, pages 133-159—There Is No Justice in History)

Hrdy, Sarah. 1997. Raising Darwin's consciousness: Female sexuality and the prehominid origins of patriarchy. Human Nature 8(1):1-49

Kamath, Ambika and Melina Packer. Feminism in the Wild: How Human Biases Shape Our Understanding of Animal Behavior. The MIT Press, 2025. (Chapter 2 – Who We Are and What We Know)

Khan, Shamus. Not Born This Way. Aeon Magazine

Lonsdorf, Elizabeth, et al. 2014. Sex Differences in Wild Chimpanzee Behavior Emerge During Infancy. PLOS One

Miller, Geoffrey, et al. 2007. Ovulatory cycle effects on tip earnings by lap dancers: economic evidence for human estrus? Evolution and Human Behavior

Monk, Julia et al. 2019. An alternative hypothesis for the evolution of same-sex sexual behaviour in animals. Nature Ecology and Evolution

Puts, David and Saeed Koohgard. “The Deadliest Primate: Context Competition and the Evolution of Human Males,” Journal of Human Evolution 220 (2026): 103898.

Roughgarden, Joan. “Challenging Darwin's theory of sexual selection,” Daedalus 136, no. 2 (2007): 23–36.

Saini, Angela. The Patriarchs: The Origins of Inequality. Beacon Press, 2023. (Chapter 1 - Domination)

Smith, Subrena E. “Is Evolutionary Psychology Possible?” (Biological Theory 15, no.1 (2020): 39-49.

Williams, Jennifer S., et al., “Considering hormones as sex- and gender-related factors in biomedical research: Challenging false dichotomies and embracing complexity,” Hormones and Behavior 156 (2023): 156:105442.

Wilson, M.L., et al. 2017. Humans as a model species for sexual selection research. Proc Royal Soc B. 284: 20171320.



No comments: