Showing posts with label The Mermaid's Tale. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Mermaid's Tale. Show all posts

Monday, February 1, 2010

The metropolitan nature of the humble slime mold

The emergence of complexity
There is a lot of interest in the nature and origin of 'complexity' these days. The word can be a buzz-word or stand-in for careful thought, or a label to help make one's work sound more original, deep, novel or important than it actually is. We're all vulnerable to such usages.

Still, many phenomena in life really do seem to be complex in the sense sometimes referred to as 'emergence': this blog post is an emergent trait relative to the ink-spots and letters of which it is composed. One can never understand it from a catalog of those components. If one can call our blog 'intelligent', it is because the inkspots were organized by an outside cause -- us -- with its organization known in advance.

Many things in life may be intelligently emergent in that sense, probably more that we tend to think; at least many animals, and even plants, seem to do organized planning rather than being simple automotons. Nonetheless, many emergent traits in both the living and non-living world seem to manifest what is called self-organizing complexity. The idea is that the emergent trait arises on its own, without an external 'designer', by the individual, local activity of its components.

You and we develop in this self-organizing way as embryos, for example, a major point in our book The Mermaid's Tale. Each cell responds to its local conditions, and step by step, the interactions of our countless cells ends up as a highly organized human. We are emergent traits relative to our cells, which in turn are emergent traits relative to the genes and other components of which they're composed.

The complexity of slime mold
In this context there is an interesting recent report of self-organizing complexity in the humble slime mold. The slime mold Physarum polycephalum exists as independent, autonomous cells much of the time. They just motor along minding their own business. But like cells anywhere, they monitor their environment, and are capable of responding to it. Under some circumstances, the individual cells interact in a striking example of self-organizing complexity.

The report shows how slime mold mimics the Tokyo rail system in efficiency, tolerance of faults, and cost. That is, as it grows and responds to environmental stresses, it forms networks connecting the individual cells, that are similar, when modeled mathematically, to such a 'real-world infrastructure network'. This is reported in Science on Jan 22, in a paper called "Rules for Biologically Inspired Adaptive Network Design," by Atsusho Tero et al.

The idea is not that we can use rail networks to understand biological systems, but the other way around.












As the authors say,
Some organisms grow in the form of an interconnected network as part of their normal foraging strategy to discover and exploit new resources. Such systems continuously adapt to their environment and must balance the cost of producing an efficient network with the consequences of even limited failure in a competitive world. Unlike anthropogenic infrastructure systems, these biological networks have been subjected to successive rounds of evolutionary selection and are likely to have reached a point at which cost, efficiency, and resilience are appropriately balanced. Drawing inspiration from biology has led to useful approaches to problem-solving such as neural networks, genetic algorithms, and efficient search routines developed from ant colony optimization algorithms.
The slime-iness of railway systems
And slime mold self-organizes without any centralized organizer, or global information: no central nervous system, no consciousness -- at least of the kind we associate with ourselves, as far as anyone knows. So, if the rules of Physarum network formation can be captured mathematically, they should be useful for planning and optimizing the functioning of non-biological networks.
Our biologically inspired mathematical model can capture the basic dynamics of network adaptability through iteration of local rules and produces solutions with properties comparable to or better than those of real-world infrastructure networks. Furthermore, the model has a number of tunable parameters that allow adjustment of the benefit/cost ratio to increase specific features, such as fault tolerance or transport efficiency, while keeping costs low. Such a model may provide a useful starting point to improve routing protocols and topology control for self-organized networks such as remote sensor arrays, mobile ad hoc networks, or wireless mesh networks.

...or not
This idea is based on the assumption that biological systems are optimized, in terms of cost, efficiency and resilience, the same outcomes that should be optimized in man-made networks, and that there are rules that determine this, that can be discerned and readily translated from the humble slime mold to the sophisticated man-made world of teleological -- purpose-designed -- networks. But slime mold cells have no blueprints, organizing committees, or overall goals. All each cell can do is react to its immediate surroundings. Any overall efficiency or resilience must have evolved indirectly by selection working on the net result of the aggregated activity of cells each working only locally.

That is very different from a committee designing a subway system or economic network. How selection's effects on the net result of slime mold aggregate patterns is manifest at the underlying genetic level is one of the major challenges in evolutionary genetics.

Selection is so indirect at the level of such complex phenomena that there is no reason to think it will be simple -- much less unitary -- at the gene level. It will have been assembled non-purposively, and with no need to optimize any of its parameters, and will likely be of no use to human urban planning committees. Evidence from attempts to map complex traits in all sorts of organisms supports the idea that it will not be simple or unitary at the gene level.

As we say in Mermaid's Tale, if there are biological rules, they can be broken. There are certainly no universal biological rules for efficiency or cost. The peacock's tail is proof of this, in that by usual considerations it's a risky, costly thing to have -- yet it purportedly has such a net advantage as to have offset its costs. Instead of some econometrician's idea of efficiency, whatever works is what evolution allows. Resilience comes closer to being a principle of life, but uncoupled from efficiency or cost. Slime mold's ancestors presumably ran into situations often enough that genes that produced sensors, signals, receptors, or whatever that led them under some circumstances to connect with neighboring cells, provided them a fitness advantage.

And there's another important way in which biological and man-made networks like rail or mobile phone systems differ, and that is that man-made networks are designed to maximize profit, and that's not an attribute relevant to biological systems, that presumably can only maximize what leads to better reproductivity. Unless survival itself is equivalent to profit, but if so, then these systems are even less equivalent than supposed because, as we say in M. T., the idea that only the fittest survive is patently false. Instead, selection weeds out the weakest organisms, while most others stand roughly comparable chances. 'Failure of the frail' is, we think, a more accurate descriptor of an organisms's chances in life than 'survival of the fittest'. In life, good enough is good enough. Period.

Somehow higher emergent properties have evolved, even in what appear to be simple organisms. It's not a surprise, because even a single cell is hard for contemporary science to explain in genetic evolutionary terms. But we still are far from understanding it adequately, which means that applying the 'lessons' of biological systems to man-made networks is largely based on assumptions that may or may not be valid, and may or may not be relevant.

Monday, June 29, 2009

The Centrality of Cooperation in Life: a first installment

A recent story in the New York Times science section about the importance of cooperation in ant colonies reminded us that we've been focused on things like disease and genetic causation in our blog for a while now. So we thought it was time to get back to other things, such as the importance of cooperation in all of biology, not just to ants.

Cooperation was in the subtitle of our book, and for a reason. Ever since Darwin's Origin of Species, whose 150th anniversary is rightly being celebrated this year, there has been what we think is an excessive belief that competition is central to the nature of life. In biology, this ethos is largely about the way that Darwinian evolution, with its stress on competition among individuals within a population, with its genetically determined winners, losers, inherent goods and bads, has fit the nature of our industrial culture's worldview. It is a convenient way to rationalize and hence justify self-interested gain by a few against the many.

Nobody can deny that there is competition in life, in the sense that some individuals do better at reproducing than others. Species have their day, and fade as other species flourish. It's an important mechanism for biological change and was a brilliant insight of Darwin, as well of others in his time (Wallace's attention was more on group competition against environmental limitations, than on individual competition). It helped demystify the origin and nature of life and its diversity.

However, it's not the whole truth about life. Instead, we think, a focus on competition draws disproportionate attention to the long-term historical aspects of life, even if the Darwinian explanation is accurate!, rather than what we can easily see every day before our very eyes. What we see everywhere, every day is mainly cooperation: among molecules within each of our cells, among cells within each individual, and among individuals. In a deep biological sense, if not in one that fits the value-loaded human word 'cooperation', even predator and prey must cooperate: both must be present for each to survive.

Classical evolutionary theory, and a lot of popular science writing based on it, assumes competition to be the fundamental force in life. But absolutely as essential to life is necessity for cooperation at all times and at all these levels--among genes in genetic pathways, among organelles in cells, among cells and tissues and organs, and in ecosystems among organisms within and between species.

And, our focus on cooperation leads us to a different view of natural selection and its importance in evolution. As we say in The Mermaid's Tale, natural selection does happen, but it depends on a lot of if's. For example, if a species over-reproduces, and if there is variation in the next generation, and if some of that variation leads its bearers to do better in a given environment, and if that's due to the inherited genome, and if the environment remains stable for long enough that this variant is favored consistently, and if the favored forms reproduce successfully, as do their offspring, and if they produce more offspring than organisms without the favored variant, then these favored organisms may become more common, due to natural selection. That is, they will be better adapted to their environment. But, all these if's must co-occur for natural selection to be an important force in change. If they are sporadic, or varying in nature and intensity, then their relative importance diminishes in relation to other aspects of life, including chance. Indeed, distinguishing chance from natural selection is no simple challenge.

No matter, to understand life in a deep sense one really has first to understand the nature of the countless cooperative interactions on which it is based. How those interactions change over long time periods of generations of cells, organisms, species, and ecosystems is important. But the interactions, and how they organize life, come first.

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Introduction to The Mermaid's Tale

We are Ken Weiss and Anne Buchanan, researchers in evolutionary biology, anthropology, and developmental and human genetics in the Department of Anthropology at Penn State University. We are frequent co-authors, and maintain our own web pages at www.anthro.psu.edu. Many of the ideas we'll discuss here are from our recent book, The Mermaid's Tale: Four Billion Years of Cooperation in the Making of Living Things (Harvard University Press, 2009).

We'll be exploring the way that genes and genomes affect life on all its dimensions; the ecological, developmental, and evolutionary. The history of biology, and in particular the discovery of evolution by Darwin and Wallace, and the discovery of genes by Mendel, has led to our current understanding of life. It allowed research strategies to develop that led to the greatest explosion of knowledge ever produced by science.

Yet, it's been restrictive. This history has led to an understanding of genes that reflects only a slice of the whole story. A simpler and, more specifically, deterministic understanding than the truth. For example, history has encouraged the notion of genes as codes for proteins, but DNA does much, much more than that and its other functions are largely ignored (even though they are understood to be important). Adding to this complexity, recent research has made it apparent that it's no longer clear what a gene even is.

Likewise, in explaining how traits arise, the usual view has been a simpler, probably simplistic, view of genetic determinism and natural selection than is the whole truth. It's easy to suggest scenarios of adaptive selection as if they were testable (which they rarely are) by implying that the adaptive traits are precisely “genetic” (or natural selection couldn't have produced them). But, when we try to identify the genetic causal basis of traits, we usually can't account for more than a fraction. This and other evidence suggest that selection is typically far weaker and less specific than its reputation.

The creation of evolutionary stories has had a strong pull on biology and other areas of modern society, because oversimplified explanations can be so appealing and easy to understand. These stories can seem so plausible that they are offered as if they must be true. This owes in part, we think, to the collapse of the understanding of deep time when thinking about evolution, that takes place when one compares ancestors or contemporary living species, and to treating them as though they in effect arose quickly, systematically, and as if driven by a continuous, fine tuning force (natural selection). That was in essence Darwin's view, but it is not actually accurate in most cases.

We think that a key fact to a broader and more accurate view of life is to see the interaction of a huge number of components. We refer to this as “cooperation” as a counter-weight to the usual theme of “competition” that is usual in strict Darwinian perspectives. It is because of many interacting components – within cells, between cells, within and between tissues and organisms -- each of them subject to mutation-driven change and chance, and each of them tolerant of variation, that life on all of its time scales, the unimaginably long evolutionary dimension, the short dimension of development, and the simultaneous one of ecology, has been possible.

So, we'll post our thoughts our reactions to papers in journals, books, and other triggers, as we hope to generate some discussion on these issues. We believe they're important to understanding life generally, as well as to understanding the genetic prediction of traits, disease risk, improving agriculture and biomedicine, concepts such as “race”, and to the use of darwinian concepts that are applied to other areas of life such as markets, social inequality, religion and others.

We hope this interests you much as it does us!