Showing posts with label Galileo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Galileo. Show all posts

Saturday, October 6, 2018

And yet it moves....our GWAScopes and Galileo's lesson on reality

In 1633, Galileo Galilei was forced to recant before the Pope his ideas about the movement of the Earth, or else to face the most awful penalty.  As I understand the story, he did recant....but after leaving the Cathedral, he stomped his foot on the ground, and declared "And yet it moves!"  For various reasons, usually reflecting their own selfish vested interests, the powers that be in human society frequently stifle unwelcome truths, truths that would threaten their privileged well-being.  It was nothing new in Galileo's time--and it's still prevalent today.


Galileo: see Wikipedia "And yet it moves"
All human endeavors are in some ways captives of current modes of thinking--world-views, beliefs,  power and economic structures, levels of knowledge, and explanatory frameworks.  Religions and social systems often, or perhaps typically, constrain thinking. They provide comforting answers and explanations, and people feel threatened by those not adhering, not like us in their views.  The rejection of heresy applies far beyond formal religion.  Dissenters or non-believers are part of 'them' rather than 'us', a potential threat, and it is thus common if not natural to distrust, exclude, or even persecute them.

At the same time, the world is as the world really is, especially when it comes to the physical Nature.  And that is the subject of science and scientific knowledge.  We are always limited by current knowledge, of course, and history has shown how deeply that can depend on technology, as Galileo's experience with the telescope exemplifies.

When you look through a telescope . . . . 
In Galileo's time, it was generally thought or perhaps believed is a better word, that the cosmos was God's creation as known by biblical authority.  It was created in the proverbial Genesis way, and the earth--with we humans on it--was the special center of that creation.  The crystal spheres bearing the stars and planets, circled around and ennobled us with their divine light.  In the west, at least, this was not just the view, it was what had (with few exceptions) seemed right since the ancients.

But knowledge is often, if not perhaps always, limited by our senses, and they in turn are limited by our sensory technology.  Here, the classical example is the invention of the telescope, and eventually, what that cranky thinker Galileo saw through it.  Before his time, we had we had our naked eyes to see the sun move, and the stars seemed quite plausibly to be crystal spheres bearing twinkles of light, rotating around us.

If you don't know the story, Wikipedia or many other sources can be consulted. But it was dramatic!  Galileo's experience taught science a revolutionary lesson about reality vs myth and, very directly, about the importance of technology in our understanding of the world we live in.

The lesson from Galileo was that when you look through a telescope you are supposed to change your mind about what is out there in Nature.  The telescope lets you see what's really there--even if it's not what you wanted to see, or thought you'd see, or would be most convenient for you to see.


Galileo's telescope (imagined).  source: news.nationalgeographic.com
From Mendel's eyes to ours
Ever since antiquity, plant and animal breeders empirically knew about inheritance, that is, about the physical similarities between parents and offspring.  Choose parents with the most desirable traits, and their offspring will have those traits, at least, so to speak, on average.  But how does that work?

Mendel heard lectures in Vienna that gave him some notion of the particulate nature of matter.  When, in trying to improve agricultural yields, he noticed discrete differences, he decided do test their nature in pea plants which he knew about and were manageable subjects of experiments to understand the Molecular Laws of Life (my phrase, not his).

Analogies are never perfect, but we might say that Mendel's picking discrete, manageable traits was like pre-Newtonians looking at stars but not at what controlled their motion.  Mendel got an idea of how parents and offspring could resemble each other in distinct traits.   In a similar way that a telescope was the instrument that allowed Galileo to see the cosmos better, and do more observing than guessing, geneticists got their Galilean equivalent, in genomewide mapping (GWAS), which allowed us to do less guessing about inheritance and to see it better.  We got our GWAScope!

But what have we done with our new toy?   We have been mesmerized by gene-gazing.  Like Galileo's contemporaries who, finally accepting that what he saw really was there and not just an artifact of the new instrument, gazed through their telescopes and listed off this and that finding, we are on a grand scale just enumerating, enumerating, and enumerating.  We even boast about it.  We build our careers on it.

That me-too effort is not surprising nor unprecedented.  But it is also become what Kuhn called 'normal science'.  It is butting our heads upon a wall.  It is doing more and more of the same, without realizing that what we see is what's there, but we're not explaining it.  From early in the 20th century we had quantitative genetics theory--the theory that agricultural breeders have used in formal ways for that century, making traditional breeding that had been around since the discovery of agriculture, more formalized and empirically rigorous.  But we didn't have the direct genetic 'proof' that the theory was correct.  Now we do, and we have it in spades.

We are spinning wheels and spending wealth on simple gene-gazing.  It's time, it's high time, for some new insight to take us beyond what our GWAScopes can see, digesting and understanding what our gene-gazing has clearly shown.

Unfortunately, at present we have an 'omics Establishment that is as entrenched, for reasons we've often discussed here on MT, as the Church was for explanations of Truth in Galileo's time.  It is now time for us to go beyond gene-gazing.  GWAScopes have given us the insight--but who will have the insight to lead the way?

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Galileo was a blogger, starry-eyed at that

Holly wrote a fine post a few weeks ago about why she blogs.  Her point?  Science blogging is a major way science is communicated now.  There are many many great science blogs out there, and the number is growing all the time.  So many academics are blogging that promotion and tenure committees and college deans are just going to have to consider it when they evaluate their faculty.  Talk about impact factor.  Sure, we can quibble about how impact should be quantified, but that's a problem that can be solved. Meanwhile, good blogging will enhance the visibility of the blogger's department and school, will increase and even make the blogger's reputation, will be a vehicle with which the blogger sharpens her thinking about the topic of the day, and most importantly, will communicate science in an immediate, effective, interactive way to anyone and everyone with access to a computer.

Blogging carries information, but with a much more immediate sense of the excitement, and the controversies, that scientific discoveries involve.  It communicates across a broad swath of society, and public engagement is important for many reasons.

But: blogging is not new!
It's well-known that Galileo was a rebel, the "Father of Modern Science", a believer in observation and experimentation, astronomer, champion of Copernicus, irritant to the Catholic church, but it's less well-known that he was a blogger.  A fine BBC 4 radio program, Great Lives, tells the story.


Galileo seems to have come by his iconoclasm naturally.  His father, Vincenzo Gallilei (1520-1591), was a late Renaissance musician, a lutenist, composer and theorist who challenged the contemporary view of music.  He wrote an important dialogue discussing alternative views of music theory, and was one of the leading voices of the musical revolution that led into the Baroque period.

It is said that the father was instrumental in the making of the son, the observational scientist, because he himself applied method to how he investigated music.  He was also a man who valued thinking about and questioning accepted theory, as well as communicating ideas, and perhaps this, too, was a major influence on his son.  But Galileo was rebellious, too.  His father wanted him to study medicine, but he was more interested in math and physics.

Galileo is reputed to have been a great teacher, a man with charisma "at the top of his game in explaining and communicating to people" (to quote physicist Dr David Berman, Galileo expert on the program).  He loved being popular, talking to important people and impressing them -- "it was a political thing for him".  It's significant that he wrote in common Italian, regional dialects even, because he was writing for people who might be interested in learning but didn't have access to rarefied Latin tomes.

Berman tells the story of Galileo being asked, "Don't people need shepherds?" His reply was something along the lines of, "People only need shepherds if you're in a jungle and you can't see the way.  If you can just illuminate the way, and everything is clear, people can see for themselves."

But, according to Berman, he didn't want to just explain.  He also wanted to change the way in which people viewed the world.  And to do this he began to dismantle the way science had been done for 2000 years, since the time of Aristotle, including the idea of absolutes such as that the moon was a perfect round sphere.  He believed in observation, in experiments that could begin to approximate the truth.

So, he made lenses for telescopes, and instruments that allowed him to make observations with which he challenged the standard view of the cosmos.  In his first book, The Starry Messenger (or Sidereus Nuncia), published in vernacular in 1610, and a quick sensational best-seller across Europe, he said, and showed with drawings, that his new tool revealed that the moon had mountains, and wasn't a perfect round sphere as had been thought for many centuries, and he wasn't afraid to say so.  "It is a very beautiful thing, and most gratifying to the sight, to behold the body of the moon, distant from us by almost 60 early radii, as if it were no farther away than two such measures..." and "Perhaps other things, still more remarkable, will in time be discovered...with the aid of such an instrument." And, later, "We shall prove the earth to be a wandering body surpassing the moon in splendor, and not the sink of all dull refuse of the universe; this we shall support by an infinitude of arguments drawn from nature."  Today's popular science writers and journalists can't top that!

What Galileo reported with such elegance was a shock, but among other things, confirmed his idea that truth had to be built from observation, not belief.  And the public had to accept the realities of reality!


It was Galileo's questioning of not just the hoary Aristotelian world-view but the nature of the universe itself that got him into trouble with the Church.  However, he was politically astute and managed not to be burnt at the stake, even at the cost of house arrest for the final years of his life.  But, the word got out.  His book, and another in dialogue form that was widely readable, promoting, among other things, the idea that the Earth revolved around the Sun. He did another, later volume also in dialogue form, about basic physics, where he studied gravity, physical forces, and even relativity before Einstein. 

Galileo knew that the way to influence people's thinking was exactly this -- accessible dialogues in classical Platonic form, that were very accessible to the lay reader, and had rather ignorant foils (e.g., a character named Simplicio) whose arguments (often those of the accepted view) were easy to dismiss in Galileo's clever way.  Here is an illustration for his 'Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems' in which he challenged the earth-centered view the universe:


These works were quite successful and, although it took a while for the Church to realize it, the ideas were catching on.  When the Church did recognize this and tried him, it wasn't for heresy per se, but for going against the papal order not to teach (though there was some doubt as to whether the order had ever been given).  The genie had been blogged right out of the bottle!

By the time he died, Galileo's books were widely known and he had been communicating, even when in house arrest imposed by the Church, with well-known scientists throughout Europe.  His ideas were not only widely known, but well-accepted.  This was so even by some of the leading Church scholars, whether or not they could publicly say so.  He was a great communicator.  He would have had great glee at the stir he caused, the attention it received, and his deep reach into society....just like today's best bloggers.

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Mooning science


Last year we honored the 150th anniversary of Darwin's Origin of Species (1859), a landmark achievement that changed the direction of science. Technically, we should have celebrated a year earlier, because Darwin and Alfred Wallace deserved joint credit for understanding the nature of evolution in a joint presentation to the Linnean Society in 1858. But never mind, because this year we have a more clearly singular and comparably transformative anniversary to celebrate.

This time it's a 400th anniversary, and the transformation was even more encompassing: it set the stage for all of modern science, even biology.

Do you recognize this picture? It stunned the world!

This was what Galileo saw through his self-made version of a Dutch invention being hawked in Paris as a child's toy: the first telescope. In Galileo's book Sidereus Nuncas (Starry Messenger), he showed that unlike the Truth accepted by everyone from Aristotle's time to Galileo's, the Moon was not a perfect sphere, part of the perfect orbs of the universe that were thought to have been created by God as such. The irregular and imperfect Earth was sinful humans' abode, but the celestial orbs were God's perfection.

Galileo's drawings illustrated clear shadows in the sunlight striking the Moon, proving that the surface was irregular, cratered. He also saw many more stars than had been thought to exist. He realized that the Milky Way was not like a nebulous cloud, but was made of countless distinct stars. And he found the moons of Jupiter, that would prove to be invaluable to navigation during the great age of sail.

Above all, the intuitively God-given universe was not as had been thought since intellectual time immemorial! The Moon looked like the Earth in the sense of having been produced by similar processes.

This and later work of course got Galileo in deep trouble with the Church, and almost got him burned at the stake. But despite insincerely recanting, and eventually dying in a kind of house arrest, Galileo and even the Popes knew that times had changed. Galileo's poking around with a telescope ushered in the Enlightenment, the era--that we're still in--of empirical, measurement and observation based, methodologically anchored ways to understand the world. Skeptics could no longer get away with appealing to the ancient Greek thinkers, nor to Scripture. The world needed to be understood properly in its own terms.

Galileo did much later work, where he essentially first showed the need for repeat observation to 'smooth out' statistical and measurement uncertainty. He dealt with gravity, the principles of motion, momentum, and much else--even the nature of relative motion. His books are enjoyable reading, too (they're in dialog form).

Galileo also began the dependence of science on theory, especially theory that could be tested quantitatively. Darwin was a self-confessed innumerate, but his theory works only because its basis, called population genetics, allows us to relate historical (but unobserved) events to present-day data. No theory (and no scripture) can match its convincing power.

So, this is an anniversary to honor!