Showing posts with label Daniel M. Parker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Daniel M. Parker. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 25, 2018

Improving access to healthcare can usually make malaria go away

Drug resistant malaria has emerged in Southeast Asia several times in history and subsequently spread globally. When there are no other antimalarials to use this has led to public health and humanitarian disasters, especially in high transmission settings (parts of sub-Saharan Africa).

Currently there is a single effective antimalarial left: Artemisinin. But malaria parasites in Southeast Asia are already developing resistance to this antimalarial, leading many in the malaria research community and in public health to worry that we will soon be left with untreatable malaria.

One proposed solution to this problem has been to attempt to eliminate the parasite from regions where drug resistance consistently emerges. The proposed strategy uses a combination of increasing access to health care (so that ill people can be quickly diagnosed and treated, therefore reducing transmission) and targeting asymptomatic reservoirs by asking everyone who lives in a community where there is a large reservoir to take antimalarials, regardless of whether or not they feel ill (mass drug administration).

In Southeast Asia malaria largely persists in areas that are difficult to access and remote. The parasite thrives in conflict zones and in the fringes of society. These are the areas that frequently don’t have strong healthcare or surveillance systems and some have even argued that control or elimination would be impossible in such areas because of these difficulties.

Today on World Malaria Day my colleagues and I published the results after 3 years of an elimination campaign in Karen State of Myanmar.  The job is not complete. But this work has shown that it is feasible to set up a health care system, even in remote and difficult-to-access areas, and that most villages can achieve elimination through beefing up of the health care system alone. In places where there are high proportions of people with asymptomatic malaria, access to health care alone doesn’t suffice and malaria persists for a longer period of time. With high participation in mass drug administration, which requires a large amount of community engagement, these communities are able to quickly eliminate the parasites as well. We are hopeful that similar programs will be expanded throughout Southeast Asia, regardless of the geographic and political characteristics of the regions, so that elimination can be achieved and sustained.

Malaria (P. falciparum) incidence in the target area over three years. The project expanded over the three years, and overall incidence has decreased.

Link to the main paper:
Effect of generalised access to early diagnosis and treatment and targeted mass drug administration on Plasmodium falciparum malaria in Eastern Myanmar: an observational study of a regional elimination programme

Link to a detailed description of the setup of the project:

Friday, February 24, 2017

Reproductive Health Funding and Why it Matters

Conflict and war can have an enormous impact on demography and population health. When active fighting breaks out in an area it can lead to large and chaotic population movements - if you’ve been paying attention to the news about conflict in the Middle East you’ve most likely seen images of huge populations fleeing countries like Syria and Iraq and the resulting influx of millions of refugees arriving in places such as Europe.

The chaotic settings in which these populations find shelter are often rife with sanitation, hygiene and other problems. Difficult, strategic decisions must be made on behalf of humanitarian agencies regarding how best to allocate limited funding to properly address the needs of these populations. Unfortunately reproductive health isn’t normally a high priority – although it really should be. One of the best ways to improve the health of a population is to address morbidity and mortality in very early childhood. Everyone in a population goes through the childbirth bottleneck. Everyone has a biological mother. Targeting these age and sex groups can have far-reaching impacts.

An IDP (internally displaced person) camp along the Thailand-Myanmar border. Photo by Suphak Nosten


Most of my work focuses on health issues along the Myanmar-Thailand border and while there has been a decrease in fighting recently, in the very near past there was active civil war and sporadic flows of refugees seeking safety in the mountains on the Thai side of the border. By the early 1980s there were many small refugee and internally displaced person camps scattered along the border. In the mid-1990s (between 1994 and 1998) most of these smaller camps were consolidated into one of 9 currently existing camps. Today, Maela refugee camp, roughly 60 kilometers north of Mae Sot, Thailand, is the largest of these camps with a current population of roughly 37,000. It has been in existence now for over 30 years.

One thing that is easy to miss in an age of constant news bombardment is that these populations, these refugee camps, don’t just disappear with the news cycle. Sometimes refugee camps last for a very long time. Today there are second-generation refugees who were born, and continue to live, in Maela camp.

Shoklo Malaria Research Unit, a field station of the Mahidol-Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, operated the only antenatal clinic in Maela camp until this past December (2016). Recently we analyzed records and data from our experiences in providing contraceptives to refugee women in this long, drawn-out refugee setting. Given the current dire refugee situation of the world, we thought our experiences might have relevance not only for the current refugee situation but also for the future, given that many people will likely be living in large refugee settings for the foreseeable future.

The first thing that became obvious from our analysis is that obtaining a good understanding of basic demographics can be rather difficult.  Information really is a first casualty of war – gaining a handle on data about the population can be difficult even decades later. Furthermore, population counts can have political implications, or conversely, population estimates are sometimes the result of political sentiments.  For Maela camp there are two main sources of population counts – one comes from the humanitarian agency that provides food (the Thai-Burma Border Consortium (TBBC)) and the other is from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) that provides humanitarian and social services. Until very recently UNHCR counts have systematically been much smaller than TBBC counts.

Population estimates have varied widely by the reporting source. We estimated the reproductive age female population for Maela camp by year using data from both TBBC (black) and UNHCR (blue) population estimates.  A loess curve (solid line) is fit to the data points and 95% confidence intervals for the curve are shown in dark gray.


Our data also show that, when provided in a socio-cultural appropriate manner, men and women in refugee settings willingly uptake contraceptives. The population we work with can properly be considered a high fertility (or natural fertility) population meaning that, with some exception, families are large and people are happy with that. But even in a high fertility population contraceptives have important health implications.  Men and women should be able to regulate their family size and spacing if they choose. Unintended pregnancies can result in incredible burdens, especially in already difficult settings, with health consequences for children, families, and entire communities leading to intergenerational transfers of poverty and nutritional deficits [1,2]. Households with few working-age adults and many dependents tend to be households with economic and nutritional deficiencies.




We also note that funding has a huge impact on the uptake of contraceptives and even the type of contraceptives that are chosen. Yes, men and women in the camp chose to readily use contraceptives, but the availability of contraceptives and the type of contraceptives available were directly influenced by funding. In this setting and in others, most of that funding could best be described as “rescue funding”, with reproductive health services normally operating on small and dwindling budgets but occasionally being “rescued” by a new source of funding. Given the importance of reproductive health (including the availability of contraceptives) and the dependence of reproductive health services on funding, funding agencies should carefully consider what they fund and should give careful consideration to funding cuts.


It is hard to draw direct, causal relationships between something like reproductive health funding and reductions in morbidity and mortality because there are complex relationships between health care delivery and health outcomes. However, we do know that during the time that SMRU operated the antenatal clinic in Maela camp both maternal and neonatal mortality decreased drastically. From 1986 to 1990 there were about 499 maternal deaths for every 100,000 births while in 2006 – 2010 there were 79 per 100,000 births [3].  In 1996 there were approximately 43.5 deaths for every 1,000 neonates and by 2011 there were 6 per 1,000 [4,5].

When funding was available, refugees in Maela camp willingly chose to use contraceptives leading to safer, better-planned pregnancies, which leads to health improvements of mother and child. A focus on reproductive health in conflict and refugee settings is extremely important and can have a drastic impact on population health. When people are given the opportunity to be more in charge of important parts of their lives, they are more likely to break out of difficult poverty cycles, and subsequently go on to live healthier lives. We believe this is a good thing.

photo by Suphak Nosten


1. Wagmiller Jr RL, Adelman RM. Childhood and intergenerational poverty: The long-term consequences of growing up poor [Internet]. Columbia University Academic Commons. 2009. Available: http://hdl.handle.net/10022/AC:P:8870

2. Corak M. Do poor children become poor adults? Lessons from a cross country comparison of generational income mobility [Internet]. IZA Discussion Paper. 2006. Available: http://ftp.iza.org/dp1993.pdf

3. McGready R, Boel M, Rijken MJ, Ashley E a., Cho T, Moo O, et al. Effect of early detection and treatment on malaria related maternal mortality on the north-western border of Thailand 1986-2010. PLoS One. 2012;7. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0040244

4. Luxemburger C, McGready R, Kham A, Morison L, Cho T, Chongsuphajaisiddhi T, et al. Effects of malaria during pregnancy on infant mortality in an area of low malaria transmission. Am J Epidemiol. 2001;154: 459–465. 

5. Turner C, Carrara V, Aye Mya Thein N, Chit Mo Mo Win N, Turner P, Bancone G, et al. Neonatal Intensive Care in a Karen Refugee Camp: A 4 Year Descriptive Study. PLoS One. 2013;8: 1–9. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0072721


Monday, May 25, 2015

QC and the limits of detection

It’s been a while since I’ve blogged about anything – things have been quite busy around SMRU and I haven't had many chances to sit down and write for fun [i] (some press about our current work here, here, here and here). 

Today I’m sitting in our home, listening to waves of bird and insect songs, and the sound of a gentle rain.  It is the end of another hot season and the beginning of another rainy season, now my 5th in a row here in Northwestern Thailand and our (my wife Amber and son Salem, and me) 3rd rainy season since moving here full time in 2013.  The rains mean that the oppressive heat will subside a bit.  They also mean that malaria season is taking off again. 


Just this last week the final chapter of my dissertation was accepted for publication in Malaria Journal.  What I’d like to do over a few short posts is to flesh out a couple of parts of this paper, hopefully to reach an audience that is interested in malaria and infectious diseases, but perhaps doesn’t have time to keep up on all things malaria or tropical medicine.  This also gives me a chance to go into more detail about specific parts of the paper that I needed to condense for a scientific paper. 


The project that I worked on for my dissertation included several study villages, made up of mostly Karen villagers, on the Thai side of the Thailand-Myanmar border. 

This particular research had several very interesting findings. 

In one of the study villages we did full blood surveys, taking blood from every villager that would participate, every 5 months, for a total of 3 surveys over 1 year.  These blood surveys included making blood smears on glass slides as well as taking blood spots on filter papers that could later be PCRd to test for malaria.  Blood smears are the gold standard of malaria detection (if you're really interested, see here and here).  A microscopist uses the slides to look for malaria parasites within the blood.  Diagnosing malaria this way requires some skill and training.  PCR is generally considered a more sensitive means of detecting malaria, but isn’t currently a realistic approach to use in field settings[ii]. 

Collecting blood, on both slides (for microscopic detection of malaria)
and filter papers (for PCR detection of malaria)


The glass slides were prepared with a staining chemical and immediately read by a field microscopist, someone who works at a local malaria clinic, and anyone who was diagnosed with malaria was treated.  The slides were then shipped to Bangkok, where an expert microscopist, someone who has been diagnosing malaria using this method for over 20 years and who trains other to do the same, also read through the slides.  Then, the filter papers were PCRd for malaria DNA.  In this way we could look at three different modes of diagnosing malaria – the field microscopist, the expert microscopist, and PCR. 

And basically what we found was that the field microscopist missed a whole lot of malaria.  Compared to PCR, the field microscopist missed about 90% of all cases (detecting 8 cases compared to 75 that were detected by PCR).   Even the expert microscopist missed over half of the cases (34 infections). 

What does this mean though? 

Lets start with how this happens.  To be fair, it isn’t just that the microscopists are bad at what they do.  There are at least two things at play here: one has to do with training and quality control (QC) while the other has to do with limits of detection.

Microscopy requires proper training, upkeep of that training, quality control systems, and upkeep of the materials (regents etc.)  In a field setting, all of these things can be difficult.  Mold and algae can grow inside of a microscope.  The chemicals used in microscopy, in staining the slides, etc. can go bad, and probably will more quickly under very hot and humid conditions.  In more remote areas, retraining workshops and frequent quality control testing are more difficult to accomplish and therefore less likely to happen.  There is a brain drain problem too.  Many of the most capable laboratory workers leave remote settings as soon as they have a chance (for example, if they can get better salary and benefits for doing the same job elsewhere – perhaps by becoming an “expert microscopist”?)

Regarding the second point, I think that most people would expect PCR to pick up more cases than microscopy.  In fact, there is some probability at play here.  When we prick someone’s finger and make a blood smear on a glass slide, there is a possibility that even if there are malaria parasites in that person’s blood, there won’t be any in the blood that winds up on the slide.  The same is true when we make a filter paper for doing PCR work.  However, the microscopist is unlikely to look at every single spot on the glass slide and there is also some probability at play here too.  There could be parasites on the slide, but they may only be in a far corner of the slide where the microscopist doesn’t happen to look.  These are the ones that would hopefully be picked up through PCR anyway. 

Presumably, many of these infected people had a low level of parasitemia, meaning relatively few parasites in their blood, making it more difficult to catch the infection through microscopy.  Conversely, when people have lots of parasites in their blood, it should be easier to catch regardless of the method of diagnosis.  


These issues lead to a few more points. 

Some people have very few parasites in their blood while others have many.  The common view on this is that in high transmission[iii] areas, people will be exposed to malaria very frequently during their life and will therefore build up some immunity.  These people will have immune systems that can keep malaria parasite population numbers low, and as a result should not feel as sick.  Conversely, people who aren’t frequently exposed to malaria would not be expected to develop this type of “acquired” (versus inherited or genetic) immunity.  Here in Southeast Asia, transmission is generally considered to be low – and therefore I (and others) wouldn’t normally expect high levels of acquired malaria immunity.  Why then are we finding so many people with few parasites in their blood? 

Furthermore, those with very low numbers of parasites may not know they’re infected.  In fact, even if they are tested by the local microscopist they might not be diagnosed (probably because they have a “submicroscopic” infection).  From further work we’ve been doing along these lines at SMRU and during my dissertation work, it seems that many of these people don’t have symptoms, or if they do, those symptoms aren’t very strong (that is, some are “asymptomatic”).

It also seems like this isn’t exactly a rare phenomenon and this leads to all sorts of questions:  How long can these people actually carry parasites in their blood – that is, how long does a malaria infection like this last?  In the paper I’m discussing here we found a few people with infections across multiple blood screenings.  This means it is at least possible that they had the same infection for 5 months or more (people with no symptoms, who were only diagnosed by PCR quite a few months later, were not treated for malaria infection).  Also, does a person with very few malaria parasites in her blood, with no apparent symptoms, actually have “malaria”?  If they’re not sick, should they be treated?  Should we even bother telling them that they have parasites in their blood?  Should they be counted as a malaria case in an epidemiological data system?

For that matter, what then is malaria?  Is it being infected with a Plasmodium parasite, regardless of whether or not it is bothering you?  Or do you only have malaria when you're sick with those classic malaria symptoms (periodic chills and fevers)?  

Perhaps what matters most here though is another question: Can these people transmit the disease to others?  Right now we don’t know the answer to this question.  It is not enough to only have malaria parasites in your blood – you must have a very specific life stage of the parasite present in your blood in order for an Anopheles mosquito to pick the parasite up when taking a blood meal.  The PCR methods used in this paper would not allow us to differentiate between life stages – they only tell us whether or not malaria is present.  This question should, however, be answered in future work. 




*** As always, my opinions are my own.  This post and my opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Shoklo Malaria Research Unit, Mahidol Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, or the Wellcome Trust. For that matter, it is possible that absolutely no one agrees with my opinions and even that my opinions will change as I gather new experiences and information.  

    





[ii]  PCR can be expensive, can take time, and requires machinery and materials that aren’t currently practical in at least some field settings
[iii] In a high transmission area, people would have more infectious bites by mosquitoes per unit of time when compared to a low transmission area.  For example, in a low transmission area a person might only experience one infectious bite per year whereas in a high transmission area a person might have 1 infectious bite per month.  

Thursday, November 20, 2014

K13 and the spread (or simultaneous emergence) of drug resistance in malaria parasites

We’ve mentioned this before, but the malaria and evolution story is complicated by multiple evolutionary tales:

  • Humans adapt to parasites
  • Parasites adapt to humans
  • Mosquitoes adapt to both

Parasites may adapt to mosquitoes too – and humans have adaptations to mosquitoes…

Malaria parasites bursting from red blood cells.  From National Geographic, June 1986 - scanned and shared online by Centuron: http://imgur.com/a/nBJb6
This post is a story about parasites developing responses to some of the things we do to get rid of them.  Malaria parasites appear to have a real knack for survival, or at least the ones that survive and spread do.  Time and time again they have developed immune responses to our antimalarials.  Sometimes it happens quickly, sometimes it seems to take decades, but each time a new antimalarial is used, parasite strains emerge that are resistant to that antimalarial drug.

Southeast Asia appears to be a “special” place with regard to the evolution of antimalarial resistance.  For whatever reason, parasites that are resistant to new antimalarials always seem to be first documented here and then sometimes appear to subsequently spread globally.  (See Klein 2013 for a nice review of some theory around this problem (2)).  For example, chloroquine resistance in falciparum malaria seems to have independently emerged in both South America and Southeast Asia, but then seems to have spread globally from Southeast Asia (3).

Plasmodium falciparum parasites are almost globally resistant now to all antimalarials except for artemisinin.  In an attempt to keep these drugs effective, there has been a huge push to only use them in combination with other antimalarials.  The mechanisms of action of most antimalarials aren’t well understood, but the hope has been that by using different drugs, with different half-lifes, and probably different modes of action, then it will be much more difficult for parasites to develop resistance when compared to monotherapy (only using a single drug).

However, despite these efforts, artemisinin resistance has emerged in Southeast Asia (4).  It is not normally complete treatment failure at this point, but rather increased clearance times.  For example, while it would once take at most two days for parasites to be cleared from a patient’s blood stream after taking a dose of artemisinin, it now can take five.  Occasionally the treatment doesn’t work at all.   This is even occurring with artemisinin combination therapy.  Strains of parasites with “reduced sensitivity” have been found in Cambodia, in part of Vietnam, and along both sides of the Thailand-Myanmar border.

Some work has attempted to understand the genetics behind artemisinin resistance but many results, including a few I’ve been a part of, have contradicted each other.  However, one region on the parasite’s chromosome 13 keeps popping up in analyses.   Earlier this year, mutations in a particular gene (Kelch 13 (K13)-propeller) were identified as being potentially important in artemisinin resistance.  The function of this gene in the parasites isn’t well understood, but it is related to protein interactions.  And it isn’t a single point mutation that seems to confer resistance.  It appears that a wide variety of mutations, any of which are occurring in this gene, lead to parasites that are less sensitive to artemisinins – and this has now been confirmed both in vitro and in vivo.

The in vitro portion of this work began with a lab strain of falciparum malaria (3d7) which was intermittently exposed to artemisinins over a period of five years(5).  Doses of the drug were applied, then removed, then applied at higher proportions over this period of time.  Parasites from each dose cycle were sequenced so that the origin of mutations could be documented and so that mutations could be compared between case and control strains.  Ultimately the researchers narrowed their search down to a mutation in a single gene that corresponded to a point in time where some of the lab parasites seemed to no longer have strong, negative reactions to the antimalarial.

[It is important, I think, to remember that drug resistance isn’t usually an all or nothing type of trait, it is much more a trait of degree.  Even in situations where an antimalarial no longer works, it is likely that by increasing the dose of that antimalarial, there will be a point at which the parasites are still sensitive.  The problem is that it also becomes toxic to the human at some point.]

Next the researchers began looking at field isolates, across space and time, in Southeast Asia.   While they didn’t always find the same point mutations, they did find mutations in the same gene, in geographic areas where parasites are known to be less sensitive to artemisinins.  In areas where parasites still appear to be sensitive to the drug, they did not find mutations in this gene.  Furthermore, the prevalence of these mutations appears to have increased in certain regions (the ones that now have artemisinin resistance) over time.  

These findings are interesting I think for several reasons.
Here we have a gene in which mutations are somehow related to artemisinin resistance in malaria parasites.  But there isn’t a single mutation that leads to this resistance phenotype – rather it seems that just about any mutation(s) in this “gene” leads to resistance.  Does that make this a gene for resistance?

Another major finding, this time from a paper that came out in September 2014 (6), is that these mutations may not be spreading in the same way that other resistant strains (like chloroquine resistant falciparum malaria, for example) seem to have.  By analyzing the flanking regions of the K13 gene, analyzing patterns of linkage disequilibrium, the authors noted that several mutations in the K13 gene appear to have emerged independently and almost simultaneously both in Cambodia and along the Thailand-Myanmar border.

Once again the implications are quite interesting, if also scary.
One is that the evolutionary response seems less rare and unique if it can happen independently and simultaneously in different regions.  Does this mean that combination therapy is not working the way we hoped it would?

Another is more directly related to public health.  Right now there are several small scale elimination attempts occurring throughout Southeast Asia.  In fact, I’m working with one of the teams doing this (briefly discussed here).  Our hope is that we can wipe out resistant strains before they spread (via mosquitoes or humans) to other regions – perhaps especially Africa.  If resistance is likely to evolve anywhere that artemisinins are being used, we may not be able to halt this spread.  I would argue that our intentions to eliminate malaria in targeted subregions are worthwhile regardless.  But, it is a bit scary nevertheless.  




*** My opinions are my own!  This post and my opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Shoklo Malaria Research Unit, Mahidol Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, or the Wellcome Trust.  


1. Network MGE. Reappraisal of known malaria resistance loci in a large multicenter study. Nat Genet. 2014;46(11):1197–205.

2. Klein EY. Antimalarial drug resistance: a review of the biology and strategies to delay emergence and spread. Int J Antimicrob Agents [Internet]. Elsevier B.V.; 2013 Feb 7 [cited 2013 Mar 8];41(4):311–7. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23394809

3. Payne D. Spread of chloroquine resistance in Plasmodium falciparum. Parasitol Today [Internet]. 1987 Aug;3(8):241–6. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15463062

4. Dondorp A, Nosten F, Yi P. Artemisinin resistance in Plasmodium falciparum malaria. New Engl J Med J … [Internet]. 2009 [cited 2013 Nov 17];455–67. Available from: http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa0808859

5. Ariey F, Witkowski B, Amaratunga C, Beghain J, Langlois A-C, Khim N, et al. A molecular marker of artemisinin- resistant Plasmodium falciparum malaria. Nature. 2014;505(7481):50–5.

6. Takala-harrison S, Jacob CG, Arze C, Cummings MP, Silva JC, Khanthavong M, et al. Independent Emergence of Artemisinin Resistance Mutations Among Plasmodium falciparum in Southeast Asia. J Infect Dis. 2014;491:1–10.

Monday, September 1, 2014

Lunch with the Captain

These days I’m having trouble finding time to write, especially to blog.

My colleagues and I are busy building a team and a large network of collaborators for a series of related malaria elimination projects.  Our initial goal in this project is to wipe malaria out in very specific populations.  If this works, and from our initial work at a smaller scale it appears as though it can, it will be vastly scaled up – reaching throughout Southeast Asia.

The impetus for this work is the so-called evolutionary arms race.  This part of the world has a very long history of popping out drug and multi-drug resistant strains of falciparum malaria (C Wongsrichanalai et al., 2001; Chansuda Wongsrichanalai, Pickard, Wernsdorfer, & Meshnick, 2002).  We (malaria workers) roll out a new line of defense (antimalarials) against our chosen adversary, and our adversary quickly develops a defense strategy against us.  These strains can subsequently move from this part of the world to others, parts of sub-Saharan Africa for example, where the malaria burden is much heavier and the results would be much more devastating (Payne, 1987).

Occasionally there are deaths from malaria infections here along the Thailand-Myanmar border (though usually the major toll the illness takes here is in time spent ill and therefore unable to work.)  Not that long ago, a 15 year old boy died from malaria.  He was not far from health care clinics that would have treated him.  The story I hear is that he was without close family members, he lived alone and worked in the agricultural fields, and that he essentially lay in those fields dying from the disease through an apparent gap in his and his community’s social network.  Everyone was devastated.  If complete drug resistance were to reach Africa, this story would be magnified in both space and time.  Even where the social networks were strong, the health clinics wouldn’t be able to adequately treat people with malaria.  The geographic reach would be huge and the numbers of death would likely dramatically increase.  This can’t happen.

Today our last, best tool against malaria is artemisinin and its derivatives.  But already throughout Southeast Asia researchers and health care workers are seeing parasites survive much longer in the human hosts after being treated with artemisinin (Ashley et al., 2014).  How much longer will it work at all?  And should we really wait to find out?  It often feels as though everyone around here has been doing the same “malaria control” game for a very long period of time, regardless of the fact that the outcome is always the same.  Our drugs stop working and we have to start over again.  Sometimes this problem is exacerbated by a lack of information and/or the dissemination of scientific knowledge.  Many of my Thai colleagues who actually work in direct malaria care in this area just learned last year (2013) that resistance to artemisinins might be occurring or even growing and spreading in their region.  A major scientific paper on this (that I’m aware of) came out 5 years ago (Dondorp, Nosten, & Yi, 2009), with rumors of it almost 10 years ago (Noedl et al., 2008)!  Shouldn’t the people who live in the war zone know that a war is happening!?  What a failure of science – and of our strategy over the long term.  It is time for a change.

So what we’re working on is a tool that we’re calling “targeted chemo-elimination.”  Essentially this is a form of mass drug administration.  That is, everyone in a targeted community would take drugs (antimalarials) regardless of whether or not they felt sick (some recent thoughts on this here, here, and here).  It is much more complicated than this though, in that it isn’t a single strong dose of the antimalarials, we’ll be using a cocktail of drugs so that we can hope to avoid further driving resistance, and since the administration will occur over time, over several stages, we’ll be able to vary this cocktail if necessary.

Logistically this is extremely difficult to pull off.  It is hard enough to get people in easy to reach populations in places like the U.S. to take medicine when they feel sick, let alone to take a vaccine that would prevent them from being sick.  How do we go about convincing people in extremely remote populations, frequently in the middle of old or continuing conflict zones, to take medicine, over a long period of time, regardless of whether or not they are currently feeling sick?  It isn’t easy.

But it can be done and the way to do it is through community engagement – drawing on notions and principles well-known in anthropology and other social sciences.  It can happen when there is understanding, trust, and social cohesion.  Sometimes these things are lacking in our target communities between members of the community, and/or between us and members of the community, and it is therefore important to build them up.  Sometimes we need to plant a seed, water it, foster it, and help it to grow.





This is exhausting work, physically, psychologically, and emotionally.

A little while back I made a trip to one of the communities in our target area, to visit local people and share some of what our project is about.  I wound up eating lunch at a table full of “freedom fighters”, some dressed in fatigues and drinking whisky out of small coffee cups.  A captain who was sitting at the table gave me a history lesson, translated to English through one of my colleagues who speaks both my tongue and the local language.  I heard stories about being betrayed by colonialists who promised these people their own land but never followed through and of people who were willing to die for that land, many of whom did in fact pay that price.



Among the things he said to me was that he admired two major things about Americans.  One is that their time is their money (time is extremely valuable).  And the other is that they realize they have a burden, to help others, that is bigger than a mountain (we were sitting at the base of a relatively large one).



I don’t know if this generalization is true of all Americans and I don’t care to go into that.  But I do know that time is of the essence and that I feel a burden.  There is a lot of work to do, and not so much time in which to do it.






*** As always, my opinions are my own.  This post and my opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Shoklo Malaria Research Unit, Mahidol Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, or the Wellcome Trust. 



Ashley, E. a., Dhorda, M., Fairhurst, R. M., Amaratunga, C., Lim, P., Suon, S., … White, N. J. (2014). Spread of Artemisinin Resistance in Plasmodium falciparum Malaria. New England Journal of Medicine, 371(5), 411–423. doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1314981

Dondorp, A., Nosten, F., & Yi, P. (2009). Artemisinin resistance in Plasmodium falciparum malaria. The New England Journal of MedicineEngland Journal of …, 455–467. Retrieved from http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa0808859

Noedl, H., Se, Y., Schaecher, K., Smith, B., Socheat, D., & Fukuda, M. (2008). Evidence of artemisinin-resistant malaria in western Cambodia. N Engl J Med, 359(24), 2619–2620.

Payne, D. (1987). Spread of chloroquine resistance in Plasmodium falciparum. Parasitology Today (Personal Ed.), 3(8), 241–6. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15463062

Wongsrichanalai, C., Pickard, A. L., Wernsdorfer, W. H., & Meshnick, S. R. (2002). Epidemiology of drug-resistant malaria. Lancet Infectious Diseases, 2, 209–218.

Wongsrichanalai, C., Sirichaisinthop, J., Karwacki, J. J., Congpuong, K., Miller, R. S., Pang, L., & Thimasarn, K. (2001). Drug resistant malaria on the Thai-Myanmar and Thai-Cambodian borders. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health, 32(1), 41–49.

Thursday, July 10, 2014

elimination now

In last years’ presidential address at the American Association of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene meeting, now published here, David H. Walker asks: “After malaria is controlled, what’s next?”  I find this to be a peculiar but illustrative question for several reasons.  I’ll return to that in a bit, but first a few terms that are frequently thrown around:

Control: reducing the numbers of new infections to an acceptable low level
Elimination: getting rid of a pathogen in the human populations within a defined region
Eradication: completely ridding a defined region, or the entire world, of a particular pathogen

In his presidential address Walker noted that “control is not easy to accomplish…” and he is mostly correct in this statement.  I say mostly correct because I’ve typically found that by having simple health care facilities available to people, malaria can be controlled quite well.  Maintaining such simple facilities, however, is the real trick because of factors such as funding shortages, corruption and other political problems, and in very remote areas it can be difficult to maintain supplies.  Furthermore, populations move around, new generations are born meaning naïve generations are subsequently exposed to diseases, the goal of keeping the numbers of cases down to a low number requires constant effort.  In the absence of such constant attention and effort, the disease can wind up taking over again.     

If you asked most malaria researchers and medical workers if they would like to see malaria eliminated, they would probably give you a resounding “yes”.  Whether or not it would be the truth, I think, is another story altogether.  Later on in Walker’s address he adds: “I do not know what the ultimate outcome of the efforts to control and eliminate malaria will be.  If malaria were to be eradicated, a large portion of our society’s membership would have to find other scientific problems to address.”

I don’t actually believe that Walker is lamenting the potential loss of one of the greatest killers in the history of mankind at the expense of economic considerations.  In fact, this post is not at all an attack on Walker’s speech, but I think it beautifully illustrates some issues that keep arising in my own mind as I’ve spent the last several years in malaria research and work.   

Recently I’ve moved out of what I think was a pure research role (as a PhD student) and into one where I help plan and execute malaria health care in areas that are quite difficult to reach, because of both the physical and political terrain in Karen State, Myanmar.  Research is still a fundamental aspect of what I do, but there is one big difference in what I do now versus what I used to do.  That is, my/our research findings directly affect our actions in the field, almost immediately.  Publishing is still important, both for my own career and for malaria science in general, but it has a secondary importance in my new position.  The goal is public health first and papers second.  I assure you that this isn’t necessarily the case in many academic settings.  

Currently there are lots of malaria researchers that spend all of their time generating and analyzing data, then writing papers on those analyses, many of which never wind up in the hands or minds of people who actually work with the disease in the field.  I see this as a failure in the dissemination of scientific findings.  Open Access efforts partially help with this problem, since many of the people who work in endemic countries don’t have the personal or institutional ability to afford journal fees.  But this is just a part of the problem.  
I find two even larger issues with what I call the malaria world (the malaria research communities plus malaria medical communities, including public health workers):

Issue 1: Economics (at the expense of public health?)

Malaria work provides a livelihood for many, many people, including me (myself?).  It means careers, salaries, wages, a way of life, for those who enter or develop a career in tropical medicine and malaria research.  What I find potentially problematic with this aspect of the malaria world is that when the control of malaria becomes an economic institution, supporting the livelihoods of people who are mostly not at risk of malaria infection themselves, doesn’t the goal become maintenance rather than elimination or even eradication?  Doesn’t the current system discourage people from really fixing the malaria problem?  I detect a little bit of worry in Walker’s presidential address, related to this very issue, and I think that this points at a major ethical flaw in the current malaria research and medicine community.  Economics is certainly important, it is even tied to malaria epidemiology and ecology in some ways, but it is not more important than wellbeing and lives. [note – I’m not saying that Walker thinks that jobs are more important, but I think his statements address a concern (in the malaria community) about the potential loss of an industry if we were actually able to get rid of malaria.]

Issue 2: Control versus elimination

As I previously discussed, malaria control in itself takes a lot of effort.  You must build up a medical infrastructure of some type for it to work, then you must staff it, and keep it maintained for it to continue to work. This has been the goal now in some areas for decades.  

But if elimination efforts are anywhere near as complicated or expensive to set up and maintain as are control efforts, and if (IF) the elimination efforts are successful, then isn’t the end result much more rewarding?  Isn't that the right thing to do?    

Now that I'm actually part of a team that is working toward elimination, I'm face to face with some of the challenges inherent in elimination versus control strategies.  Elimination really does requires a different mind set.  Given that basically everyone has been doing the control bit for the last 5 decades, there isn't much collective knowledge in what does and doesn't work with regard to elimination.  We're having to figure much of this out as we go.  

Returning to Walker’s question though, (“After malaria is controlled, what’s next?”), it appears to me that all too often, nothing is next.  Control turns into maintaining the disease, rather than actually progressing in our public health efforts.  People get used to what they're doing and frequently don't like to change, even when it is the right thing to do.  It is time for change.  In at least some places right now, and everywhere in the near future, it’s time to move toward elimination.  Don’t worry; there are other bad diseases out there to worry about afterward.   




*** My opinions are my own!  This post and my opinions do not necessarily reflect those of Shoklo Malaria Research Unit, Mahidol Oxford Tropical Medicine Research Unit, or the Wellcome Trust.  


Walker, David H. (2014) "After malaria is controlled, what's next?" Am J Trop Med Hyg 91(1): 7 - 10. 


Wednesday, April 9, 2014

development through research??

15 years ago, when Chief Khunchai first took a job managing a malaria clinic on a remote stretch of the Thailand-Myanmar (still Burma at that time) border, there weren’t year round roads, there was no electricity, no telephones, and the endemic guerilla warfare between the Karen and the Burmese didn’t pay much attention to the international border.  A Karen military base was just over the mountain on the other side of the river.  Sometimes when fights broke out, mortars would fly across the river and land near the clinic.  It wasn’t personal; such things don’t always stop at international borders.

Moei River - the international border between Thailand and Myanmar


In the hot season temperatures regularly exceed 90° Fahrenheit, at midnight.  Without electricity, every degree above 80 is obvious.  There is a constant trickle of sweat behind your ears and down your lower back, and you eventually stop mistaking this feeling for mosquitoes and other insects that want your blood.

In the wet season, everything is permeated by the omnipresent moisture.  Pencils won’t write on paper, which has been collecting moisture from the rain and from your sweat, and pens make thick smudges on anything they touch.  Records are hard to keep.  The landscape is almost fluorescent green during this season.  The dichotomy between inside and outside is a false one.  Even the walls grow green with algae, plants and vines work their ways into the cracks and struggle for a nook or cranny to fill and exploit.

In this part of the world, the sun goes down at a consistent time pretty much year round – 6:30.  But this malaria clinic is surrounded by sharp mountain peaks and karst rock formations, and these geological entities hide the sun more quickly.  If work was to be done after 5pm or so, it was done by candle.  Malaria diagnoses would have to wait until tomorrow, when the light from the sun could be used in the small circular mirror that illuminates the slides and lenses in the microscope.

microscope for detecting malaria


Contacting the outside world could be done using military styled radios, through a tall antenna that stretched out of the top of the clinic.  This was handy in case people needed to be evacuated because of flooding, fires, or fighting to relay information about the epidemiological situation, or to request shipments of dwindling medical supplies.  A lighting rod was placed at the other end of the building to keep people from getting barbecued during storms.

a storm over the Moei

Over the years, Chief Khunchai has become a much respected member of society.  He knows almost everyone in the district in some way or another, and he holds a lot of political weight.  His office gets nicer over time.  Still the chief of a malaria clinic, he looks back on those days with little nostalgia.  He shudders a little when he tells me about working by candle light and having to worry about the fighting.  Yes, today things are quite different.  

He now manages a new malaria clinic about 35 miles south of the one he started at.  This malaria clinic has electricity.  At first this meant an electric microscope and lights, and that work could be done at night.  It also meant fans, which make work much more bearable during certain times of the year.  Even more recently, it meant that sealed doors could be installed in the main room and office so that wall AC units could also be installed.  AC isn’t frequently used, but it is very nice to turn the units on when there are special guests (usually political superiors) visiting.  

There are at least three different large malaria projects running in the district, and each of these projects has hired staff that are housed at the clinic.  A room was built on to the back so that they would all have desk and computer space.  A little data entry and a lot of facebook and youtube happen in that room.  

In the same period of time, malaria cases appear to have decreased, even while the population of the area has increased.  This is especially the case with regard to cases in Thai nationals.  Most cases here are in Myanmar nationals or Karen people with no nationality.  In fact, it is entirely possible that today there are more malaria-related personnel in Thailand than there are cases of malaria in Thai people each year.  That is, I think, a very strange thing.  



I begin with this story so that I can paint a picture of a kind of situation that I think has occurred in many parts of the world.  Malaria persists in places where “development”, for whatever reason, hasn’t extended.  One (I) could easily argue that such “development” is actually destructive in many ways, but it is hard to argue that life for many people hasn’t become easier.  And malaria cases have gone down at the same time.  

At least some of that development must be a direct result of the research cash that flows in from major malaria research projects and initiatives.  Those data entry people in the back facebooking can now purchase relatively nice motorcycles; some of the managers might even buy cars.  It’s not just the malaria clinic that has changed, there are also new restaurants, roads that are mostly good (or equally bad) year-round rather than only being traversable during the dry season, and more recently, a 7-11.  I joke that next year there may be another 7-11 across from that 7-11, but you may not understand unless you’ve recently visited Bangkok.  All of these things have associated workers who in turn buy stuff from places that also employ people.  In this part of the world, and I think in other parts too, malaria is mostly a “rural” disease.  It exists in places without 7-11s and year-round roads.  As you pave the ground for those roads and build concrete jungles, this particular disease tends to go away.  

And I find in this all a great irony.  

I’ve previously heard jokes that the best way to get rid of a disease is to try to study it.  I think this means I’m not the first to notice what is happening.  

The malaria industry is huge and there is a lot of money in it.  Frustratingly, much of that money winds up getting wasted through corruption and through things that ultimately aren’t necessary for what I think really matters: helping people who are sick with malaria, or even better, getting rid of malaria.  

For that matter, a question I’ve increasingly worried about over the last several years is: Should we really be setting up an industry, a vast network of jobs, that are all geared toward halting a disease?  Will these people really be motivated to stomp out the very thing (in this case, malaria) that keeps their own lives, at least economically, afloat?  Is that why people heatedly argue that we should be trying to control malaria rather than just get rid of it??!  Even more-so, while I can see the value in having electricity at a malaria clinic for diagnosis purposes, is AC, more space, new desks, etc. all relevant for combating the malaria problem?  

But perhaps there is another way to look at this too.  That is, perhaps all those research dollars that get pumped into malaria research do actually work.  I think they really do.  I just don’t think they work in the way that any of us really intend for them to.  They wind up spurring the local economy, they boost peoples’ economic well-being, and then in some cases and for some extremely complex reasons, people who move out of deep poverty are no longer faced with the immediate health consequences of that poverty.  For them, malaria isn’t any longer an immediate danger.  They can sit in a nice office, preferably behind a nice fan and in front of a nice computer screen, and check boxes on the computer that correspond to a malaria patient’s age and sex (or to a “like” button on someone’s post).  After half a life’s worth of work in less-than-ideal conditions, maybe it is more than OK that Chief Khunchai no longer has to dodge mortars or work by candlelight.  Hell, maybe he deserves the occasional AC – I certainly convince myself that I do.  

Sometimes I’ve gotten quite riled-up by the ways I see malaria research dollars getting spent but maybe I’ve completely missed the point.  Maybe all that really matters is that those dollars with the malaria name on them wind up having the effect that (I think) we all ultimately want.  Even if the functional mechanism behind this cause and effect has basically nothing to do with the one(s) that many of us think matters.      



*** I know several "Chief Khunchais" - but this name is of course made up

Friday, March 14, 2014

Kah Tah Blay Learning Center Graduation

by Daniel and Amber Parker

In a break from what we normally blog about here at MT, today my wife and I thought we’d share some of what we’ve been up to lately.

We’ve been living at a field site on the Thai-Myanmar border since July 2013 and today we’d like to gloat a little about a project that we’ve been involved with over the last year – Kah Tha Blay Learning Center (KTBLC). KTBLC is a small school along the Thai-Myanmar border about 2 hours north of Mae Sot.

The school rose from a need to educate young Karen adults because education opportunities, especially on the Burma side of the border, were almost completely absent (some boys could attend limited schooling provided by monks at Buddhist temples).  Until very recently, the Karen were involved in the longest continuous civil war in recorded history – lasting over half a century.  During this time most able-bodied men became soldiers, meaning that they had little role in community developments etc.  Villages that existed in conflict zones were forced to frequently move, with Burmese military troops setting them on fire, often as villagers slept.    

A lot of knowledge was lost during this time.  Traditional approaches to farming were among them.  For those who wound up in refugee camps on the Thai side of the border, very little farming continued at all – there is extremely limited land available and rice is provided for each household.  For these people, some safety was provided by the rice and relative protection of the Thai side, but traditional subsistence practices and leadership roles were lost.  A major goal of the school is to address these issues. Kah Tha Blay means Freedom Country.

The school headmaster and principal are Karen, as are several of the teachers.  Funding comes through an NGO, Project Umbrella Burma, which is based out of Canada – however the ultimate goal is to have the school completely self run (with Karen people raising the necessary funds) in the near future.

The school headmaster (Kshakalu) at Karen New Years Celebration

Singing around the campfire



The school has physically moved around a bit over the years, beginning within a refugee camp as a school/hostel and then expanding to include a junior college for students who passed the 10th grade (there are very few opportunities for students to continue education after the 10th grade in the refugee camp(s)). The junior college was originally built in Burma, but due to the continuing violence and safety concerns, had to eventually be moved to the Thai side of the border where it is located today. Student ages range from about 18 to 25.  Because the school is on the Thai side of the border, they learn Thai, raise a Thai flag in the morning, and say the Thai pledge of allegiance (followed by a Karen-styled version of “We shall overcome” – directed (I think) at the Burmese conflict).  

Perhaps one of the most interesting, probably provocative, aspects of this school is that one of its goals is to address the very real “brain drain” problem.  That is, the most educated Karen usually wind up moving abroad and rarely or never return to their home communities.  The students who are accepted into KTBLC have promised to return to their communities when they are done learning, even if they go on for further training after KTBLC.  So far, it looks like many actually do wind up going back to their homes.  On an individual basis, we see students who we think would do great in a university setting, and we very much want to help them pursue that sort of path.  These are probably the same ones who will go on to be strong leaders that the Karen need in Karen state.
 
The school is set in a very small village, in a terraced rice paddy field that is surrounded by mountains.  A typical day for them begins early in the morning, when they begin chores around the school or participate in extracurricular activities like sports and traditional “Don” dancing.  They grow much of their own food (which is part of their education process), cook their own food, and are in charge of the upkeep of the school buildings and grounds.  They take regular courses each school year including subjects like English, Community Health, Thai and Math, supplemented with various other topics that volunteers provide throughout the school year - Leadership, Photography, Journalism, etc. The students prepare lunch during the middle of the day and dinner after classes end in the evenings followed by more chores and study hour before lights out. Some are able to visit family members in the refugee camps on the weekends while the others (without family in the camps) remain on campus. 

typical landscape in the area


Over the last half year or so we have volunteered out at the school, teaching public health, computer skills, and creative writing.  Since English isn’t their first language, it can be quite a challenge.  Sometimes they don’t completely understand the knowledge that we try to pass on, but it is probably the case that they at least benefit from hearing English being spoken by a native speaker or from hearing about and seeing pictures from parts of the world (e.g. the U.S.) about which they know very little.  

We’ve grown quite attached to these students.  It’s hard not to.  These are students who REALLY want to be in school, who are thirsty for whatever knowledge someone will pass on to them, even if it’s not a subject that they’re particularly interested in.  

They work hard, but there is also a captivating form of light-heartedness in everything that they do.  Moments are never dull.  Quiet periods during the day, for example while working independently, are filled with students singing; sometimes a single student, other times the whole class. They are very community oriented and enjoy working and learning together. 

several of our students watching Karen Revolution Day ceremonies

Revolution Day 2014

students performing a skit

students performing a skit (note the banana-leaf glasses)

At times during our lectures or discussions a flock of ducks or chickens would wander through the classroom (which are located outdoors). This is so normal for the setting that a student normally stands up and begins herding the strays out of the class while everyone else goes about their business… 

Last week we were just barely able to make their graduation.  We flew back from State College, PA on March 4th, with layovers in Washington D.C.; Tokyo, Japan; Bangkok, Thailand; Maesot, Thailand, and then a few hours drive north to where we live.  Not all cylinders were firing – but we were extremely happy to see them receive their diplomas, to meet their extremely proud family members, and to participate in the ceremonies.  

On the students’ faces we saw a mixture of emotions.  They’re extremely proud of their accomplishments thus far, as they should be.  Many are worried about the future.  Now they have to go off and do something other than be students at KTBLC.  Uncertainty can be scary.  That uncertainty isn’t just for them at an individual level though; Karen State is changing at an increasing (alarming?) rate.  Fighting has mostly ceased, roads are now being built, electricity is reaching rural villages, new schools are emerging, development has finally come and that means the only certain thing right now is that some things will be different.  And that is the world that these students will be returning to.  They return as some of the most educated people in their respective communities and many of them will be taking leadership and public health roles in those communities, starting schools of their own, etc.      

Monday, November 25, 2013

the border

Sometimes people ask me why I work on malaria in Thailand.  Most of the malaria in the world, most of the deaths from malaria in the world, occur in Africa.  So if I want to study malaria, why not study in Africa?  An honest answer would have to include the opportunities that happened to fall in place, but there are real substantive reasons to be very interested in malaria in Thailand.

What I actually study is what we sometimes call “border malaria” – a strange pattern where malaria clusters along international borders.  This is the pattern in Thailand, where malaria is almost completely absent in the central plains.

Probably the easiest way to think about these maps is: A. is where the falciparum malaria is, and B. is where it could be.  Maps from the Malaria Atlas Project: http://www.map.ox.ac.uk/

Understanding why this pattern occurs isn’t easy.

If you look at a elevation map of Western and Northwestern Thailand you’ll see that much of that border consists of mountains and hills.  You can't tell from this map, but those same areas are also heavily forested.  This aspect of the landscape has a whole lot to do with the persistence of malaria in this area.  It has a lot to do with ecology (both human and mosquito), politics, demography, economics, and a few other sociocultural factors.



These mountain areas aren’t heavily populated in the sense that Bangkok or Chiang Mai are, but they have been inhabited for a long time.  Along with the Thai who live in this area, most of the inhabitants consist of what are commonly called Hill Tribes.  These are groups of ethnic minorities who live, both literally and metaphorically, on the margins of Thai society.  They have different cultures, different languages, different houses, slightly different ways of making a living, and ultimately different health problems.

They also live in a vastly different ecology than does most of the rest of the country.  The farther away you get from big cities, the more the roads and other forms of infrastructure (including hospitals and clinics) crumble away.  In the wet season everything is soaking wet and the rivers spill over their edges while in the dry season it can be quite hot.  But it’s also a beautiful place, one of my favorite in the world.  I find both the landscape and the people to be awe-inspiring.  



My main study population here is the Karen.  Living along the international border, on the edges of both Thai and Burmese society, things have been quite difficult for the Karen for a long time.  They spent well over half a century at war with the Burmese military and the symptoms of this warfare are far reaching.  The Burmese military would sometimes attack Karen villages, rebel fighters, farmers, school children, monks and all – and villagers would flee across the border into the relative safety of Thailand.  Some set up makeshift refugee camps while others settled into official camps that have existed now for decades.  At times these camps, with huts built almost on top of each other and constructed of bamboo and dried heliconia leaves, would be set ablaze by the Burmese.  (Here is a nice publication about some of this history, from The Border Consortium).

Mae La camp, which is about 30 kilometers south of where I live, has around 50,000 people living in it, including some who are third generation camp inhabitants. Image from: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mae_La_refugee_camp     
Many things were lost during these years.  Don’t get me wrong, plenty of Karen remained resilient and strong throughout these hard times – they are a lively and outwardly happy people who love to sing and dance, but Karen elders and their knowledge were killed.  People lost limbs to the many land mines that litter this border region.  Some lost their sanity and others lost their hope.  Children lost their chances at education.  All of this for over half a century.  Seriously, imagine a society that hasn’t been able to settle down and focus on families and communities for over 50 years.  Perhaps the greatest loss in this time has been the cohesiveness of such social institutions.

Malaria has been a major cause of both death and sickness for the Karen throughout this time, but these types of conditions make it difficult to focus on a single problem or to even do anything about it.  As malaria researchers have found all over the world, when people have more pressing "for sure" problems (like needing to fill their bellies with food), it is hard for them to worry about invisible parasites in tiny mosquitoes.  Also, preventing malaria means that communities and households need to be working together for this goal.  Community members must work together to ensure people are educated about where the disease comes from and how to prevent it.  Standing water needs to be covered, villages should be well drained, people need to use mosquito nets and they need to seek treatment when they’re sick.  But these are all things that don’t happen when communities are frequently uprooted in the middle of the night only to be forced to move somewhere else, perhaps deeper into mosquito infested forests and hills, to get away from soldiers who wish them harm.  After having to do this several times, people are likely to give up on building permanent communities.  What’s the point when you’ll probably just have to move again one night?  

On the other hand, the Thai have been in a comparatively better position to handle the malaria problem and for most of the country that is exactly what they’ve done.  For most Thais, malaria is a concern of the past.  While I can’t speak for the Thais, I also think many feel as though their neighbors frequently weigh them down.  Thailand is more economically developed than its mainland neighbors (especially Cambodia, Myanmar, and Laos).  Many migrants from these economically poor regions come to Thailand seeking work.  The Burmese are their ancient enemies and while the Karen certainly aren’t the Burmese, they still come from across that border and use the resources (including health care) that are available in Thailand.  The situation is in some ways quite reminiscent of the Southwestern United States, complete with the ill-feelings that some have for the migrants that come across the Mexico border.  The malaria researchers who’ve worked here for a long period of time also have fresh memories of this border area as a dangerous place, where even elephants and water buffalo sometimes step on landmines that were buried years ago and where mortars inadvertently wind up sunk in neighbors front yards.

But money for malaria control and prevention flows into Thailand from lots of different sources (more on that in a future post).  Aid that is specifically geared toward these border populations, frequently channeled through the numerous NGOs in this area, also flows in from many parts of the world.  Yet while the problem almost certainly won’t be fixed in the absence of money, the money must be efficiently directed.  The money doesn’t always make it to the people that need it the most.  Very remote populations that are still on the Burmese side have long been neglected, if for no other reason than because they’re very difficult to reach.  More recently though, there are signs of peace (this is a big point of contention among the Karen!)  More foreigners are allowed into Myanmar/Burma and this means that medical teams have better access to some of these communities.  Even while this is occurring though, there are remote Karen populations on the Thai side that remain ignored.  When I first began working on malaria in Thailand, the story I heard was that most of it came from Burma via migrants.  While that does sometimes happen, it is increasingly obvious to me that small pockets of very high malaria transmission on the Thai side of the border remain.  It’s just that those communities with the most malaria seem to mostly be  non-Thais (for that matter, a lot of people in these areas have no official nationality at all).

And since political reforms have begun in Myanmar, and outside nations have been dropping their sanctions, funding for border related NGOs and other groups has been drying up (see here, here, and here, for example).  I suppose that it was only sexy to donate money when there was an active war going on.  I assure you that the war zone here on the border, and all of its implications, still exists today.  (To be fair, many people want to move their funds into Myanmar.  With that comes the likelihood that some of that money will go to the government.  In my opinion, it also means that many people on the Thai side are abandoned).

I admit that I've only worked on malaria in a few places, but I can't imagine a place in the world where malaria is more obviously linked to social, economic, and political factors.

Now, back to the question that I began this post with: Why do I study malaria here?  Aside from the fact that I just really love this part of the world – there is hope on the horizon and that hope keeps me going.  At one point I was a starry eyed anthropology student who wanted to do something about infectious diseases.  I went to where some of those infectious diseases were, began working with other people in public health (not just Thais), and I found out that not everyone was as passionate as I.  In fact, public health work is a job.  Those malaria funds that flood into this part of Thailand create jobs for people, and some of those people aren’t necessarily concerned about malaria control, prevention, or eradication - some of them just want a job.  And I think this gets at a deeper, more troubling problem that must exist anywhere where there are people who work with health problems.  If you are completely effective, if you actually get rid of a disease, you've actually worked yourself out of a job...

But malaria incidence in Thailand has decreased dramatically since the 1960s and it may even be going down in parts of Burma/Myanmar.  Political changes in Burma/Myanmar mean that there is much less fighting, in this region anyway, than there has been for a very long time.  The resources are here, even if I don’t think they’re always directed in the most efficient way.  I think that many of the young Karen adults are now in a place to learn new skills, take leadership roles, and to gain back much of what they’ve had to do without for so long.  The implication of these things, in particular the latter, I think is that we will see very real changes in the overall health and well-being of the Karen in the very near future.  I’d love to be a part of that.